• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Make all CDT discussions public record

Two Factor Authentication User
SytheSteamer
Signature of the Month Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Christmas 2016
Christmas 2019
Easter 2016
Former OMM
In Memory of Jon
Member of the Month Winner
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
St. Patrick's Day 2018
Summer 2019
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Toast Wallet User
Verified Overwatch Diamond
I don't see why it would be wrong for us to post the monthly check in thread publicly.


This way we have a summary of what has been done shown to the public without leaking anything and doing damage to the internals. +it helps people stay accountable.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
How can events be organised in public? Makes no sense

Well if you want the public to attend your event you have to organize at least part of it in the public. If it's a contest or something that needs to have private answers, fine plan it in private but release it after the fact.

Also don't want the CDT to change how they communicate based off of the fact that the public can see everything they do. A great example of this is a template thread for a summer flash game we are going to have. People who will look into our forum will see the game beforehand and probaly finish the event before it's even completed.

It gives people who are looking into our forums an unfair advantage at alot of our events. Ever parciptate in a scavenger hunt? Not anymore.

If you change the way you communicate based on whether you are in public or not you shouldn't be in the position to comment privately.

In regards to this, I'm supporting releasing the threads once events are completed/polls close. Opening up the section for public view is stupid.

Syed said there was a lot of suggestions floating around in there. Can those be made public? Part of the reason I want the entire section is because I don't trust people to actually make things public. The default should be public, not private.

I don't see why it would be wrong for us to post the monthly check in thread publicly.


This way we have a summary of what has been done shown to the public without leaking anything and doing damage to the internals. +it helps people stay accountable.

This doesn't solve the trust issue.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Discord Verified
In Memory of Jon
Heidy
PHP Shit Show 2k26
STEVE
Summer 2016
Syed said there was a lot of suggestions floating around in there. Can those be made public? Part of the reason I want the entire section is because I don't trust people to actually make things public. The default should be public, not private.
I don't see a problem with that as long as it doesn't interfere with anything the CDT has planned.
 
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Former OMM
Detective
STEVE
In Memory of Jon
Poker Chip
Pokémon Trainer
Some like it hot
Make the CDT, PR, and Tech Core all one big "Community Building" squad that has different subsets and there can be a record keeper who releases the monthly updates/info of everything.

All in all yeah, make it public, take feedback, and force the teams to somehow work together for a common goal of success (isn't that what we're doing) so this doesn't turn into a pissing contest where people are trying to mark their territory.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
Make the CDT, PR, and Tech Core all one big "Community Building" squad that has different subsets and there can be a record keeper who releases the monthly updates/info of everything.

All in all yeah, make it public, take feedback, and force the teams to somehow work together for a common goal of success (isn't that what we're doing) so this doesn't turn into a pissing contest where people are trying to mark their territory.
I'd support the idea of an archivist who worked with all three teams to publically archive old threads. I'd still like as much as possible to happen in public rather than in private. The TCT will likely have a lot that can happen directly in public but we can figure that out as we get up to speed as a team.
 
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Former OMM
Detective
STEVE
In Memory of Jon
Poker Chip
Pokémon Trainer
Some like it hot
I'd support the idea of an archivist who worked with all three teams to publically archive old threads. I'd still like as much as possible to happen in public rather than in private. The TCT will likely have a lot that can happen directly in public but we can figure that out as we get up to speed as a team.

As long as there's still a place for private information that may be sensitive then that's fine. My only real concern is ensuring the teams work together to fulfill the common goal of aiding Sythe's community
 
Baby Yoda
Heidy
Hoover
Extreme Homosex
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Rio 2016
Summer 2016
Paper Trading Competition Participant
Member of the Month Winner
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
PHP Shit Show 2k26
As long as there's still a place for private information that may be sensitive then that's fine. My only real concern is ensuring the teams work together to fulfill the common goal of aiding Sythe's community

I completely agree there should be transparency. I see nothing wrong with releasing information to the public that isnt sensitive material.
 
<3 n4n0
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Support Center Participant
Writing Competition Winner
In Memory of Jon
Valentine's Day 2017
Valentine's Day 2016
Pokémon Trainer
Togepi
Penguin
Syed said there was a lot of suggestions floating around in there. Can those be made public? Part of the reason I want the entire section is because I don't trust people to actually make things public. The default should be public, not private.

Tell @Syed to stop leaking information, nothings been decided on the outcome of publicity yet. ;)

The idea of having suggestions floating around in there is to determine what would be good, or pencil to paper ideas on what could happen. We then if necessary make these idea's public and ask the community what they would like to see with these ideas. Other times it is not possible to do so, because it could ruin the event etc. If you have these ideas immediately on show to the public, it wouldn't have the same effect. Like Tyler said, there are a lot of event planning which need to be hidden. So I don't support live events being open to public.

There are a few things I would not mind being public.

Applications; whether that be the sole application itself, or the voting as well - possibly just the application. I'm aware of there being a stigma regarding if a CDT member voted no or had negative reasons it could be a downer for the new applicants. I don't see why it wouldn't be unfair to show the community the reasons for why you wanted to join the CDT, what skills you have to offer, what has motivated you to apply.

I don't see why we can't make events which have finished be publicly archived; have the 'making-of' event#1. That way the whole community can see for themselves who participated where, how and what was done behind the scenes. Alongside the monthly check in thread. This would be a great way to receive feedback from the community if they can see what was done. I've

Some voting. events such as Monthly Graphics Competition, are open to public voting. I agree possibly in future we can have events which have entries such as photos could have public voting. - I don't see much wrong with this being a public voting. If entries are hidden, then the voting can be public, this way we minimize the whole idea of votes being based on a popularity contest.

This is so far what I can think of, off the top of my head.
 
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
In Memory of Jon
Dragon Claws
Former OMM
With the exception of applications, voting on applications, and organization of events during that event, I don't see why not. Applications should be made private to respect the privacy of the user applying. If they want it public or don't mind, they're free to post it on the application thread imo. Voting on applications should be private for many of the reasons mentioned above. And an event is no fun if organized in the public. Many events, such as the halloween haunted houses would be no fun because the answers and structure of the event would be public for everyone participating to see, eliminating the fun of it.

But discussions I don't see why not. Infact, I'd love to see threads go up a month before december asking if anyone has any ideas for christmas events. I think that can get people really engaged to participate with the CDT, and can even help show the CDT some people who are encouraged and want to be apart of making these events. So really, almost nothing bad can come of it. If anything, it'll help the CDT grow and help make improved events that even more people in our community can enjoy.
 
In Memory of Jon
Gohan has AIDS
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
Make the CDT, PR, and Tech Core all one big "Community Building" squad that has different subsets and there can be a record keeper who releases the monthly updates/info of everything.

All in all yeah, make it public, take feedback, and force the teams to somehow work together for a common goal of success (isn't that what we're doing) so this doesn't turn into a pissing contest where people are trying to mark their territory.

We can have a public event archive yeah but the live threads should remain as is

This can be done easily. Just as there is a "Discord Log" in the SF, logs of event discussions can be put out to the public. But making it live I don't think is a good idea, there's no point in having a team then.

A way to avoid that, would be discussing things with the community first before starting team discussion. I agree with Roary on this.
 
Verified Hardcore
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Twitter
Writing Competition Winner
Community Participant
Paper Trading Competition Participant
Detective
Facebook Promoter
In Memory of Jon
Le Kingdoms Player
Christmas 2020
Christmas 2023
Easter 2024
HamSanta
March Madness
May the 4th Be With You
PHP Shit Show 2k26
St. Patrick's Day 2024
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Butt (Bring up the thread)
Bump is incorrect as that means Bring up my post, this thread isnt mine so have to use Butt
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: SuF
Verified Hardcore
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Twitter
Writing Competition Winner
Community Participant
Paper Trading Competition Participant
Detective
Facebook Promoter
In Memory of Jon
Le Kingdoms Player
Christmas 2020
Christmas 2023
Easter 2024
HamSanta
March Madness
May the 4th Be With You
PHP Shit Show 2k26
St. Patrick's Day 2024
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
With the exception of applications, voting on applications, and organization of events during that event, I don't see why not. Applications should be made private to respect the privacy of the user applying. If they want it public or don't mind, they're free to post it on the application thread imo. Voting on applications should be private for many of the reasons mentioned above. And an event is no fun if organized in the public. Many events, such as the halloween haunted houses would be no fun because the answers and structure of the event would be public for everyone participating to see, eliminating the fun of it.

But discussions I don't see why not. Infact, I'd love to see threads go up a month before december asking if anyone has any ideas for christmas events. I think that can get people really engaged to participate with the CDT, and can even help show the CDT some people who are encouraged and want to be apart of making these events. So really, almost nothing bad can come of it. If anything, it'll help the CDT grow and help make improved events that even more people in our community can enjoy.

I like this. PR, CDT and TC should be made this way. Like this the PR, CDT and TC members also have a reason to do things quickly as people can see if you are slacking.
 
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
We will be publishing all event threads after the events finish as soon as get a forum to do so
i think that's probably the best solution here. there's a good reason to keep active threads separate, and honestly most of them are boring anyway.

fwiw, i think the response to one poorly-managed CDT event being "ok, make it public" is an overreaction, but honestly now that CDT is a shell of its former self i dont really mind if its all made public.

I like this. PR, CDT and TC should be made this way. Like this the PR, CDT and TC members also have a reason to do things quickly as people can see if you are slacking.
quicker ≠ better
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
i think that's probably the best solution here. there's a good reason to keep active threads separate, and honestly most of them are boring anyway.

fwiw, i think the response to one poorly-managed CDT event being "ok, make it public" is an overreaction, but honestly now that CDT is a shell of its former self i dont really mind if its all made public.


quicker ≠ better
The poor event was just the catalyst of change, not the reason to change.
 
Back
Top