All who've opposed the idea on this thread have yet to give a substantive reason for why it shouldn't exist. The strong disapproval of this stems from many not being able to attain/sustain the rank. Rather selfish.. Not unexpected.
VIP/Donor rank are interchangeable. Any rank would be comparable to SVU if we're talking about how the average user would interpret it's value, it's natural. The problem with SVU was the misleading label, use of fake information, and ease of access.
Extra donation perks will not have the same impact, nor significance as a subscription package. Why? A majority of the community are already $200+ donors. Unless we're making these perks for $700+ donors, then the impact isn't there. Even speaking from a long term perspective, the current perks and addition of new perks won't have much contrast in incentive. Also, VIP would be exclusive, so donating regularly wouldn't be out of the question.
The way you're talking makes it seem like this is being forced on you. It would be optional, not mandatory. It would be another way to support the site. You want him to make money without having users pay for something? That's wishful thinking, especially since advertisements/donations are the backbone for the sites revenue.