How would you rate? (Beginner , medium, semi, pro)

[Barratt]

Great, would love to see it!

Great I will pm you when finiched

All you do is talk shit about other peoples graphics, and act like you know everything about graphics there is to know, and hey maybe you do, I haven't even seen any of your work. But instead of saying that it's shit, maybe tell them how they could make it better.

OT: definitely have a lot to learn. work on the lighting, are you using c4d?

Ill let you argue that out

please revert back to where he talks shit? he gave points to improve. Back off internet hero.

OT: i would rate you a beginner even tho i just passed that stage. KIU and get better mate.

KIU? and dont worry ill keep practicing

He asked for a rate and I rated him, go up and read the OP. Then he disagreed with both me and surj when we rated him the same. He is just wanting someone to build him up and I was just being honest and explaining why I rated him that. If he wanted a CnC I can easily provide a CnC.

And you must not have any experience in a real graphics community. It isn't talking shit, it's called critique. You post what is wrong with the piece. If you're coming into the GFX section I am going to be honest with you and not bullshit around trying to make you feel good.

So if you want to continue to talk shit then please PM me and I can explain in-depth.

OT:

What you need to work on is your composition. Just having straight on text with a glow on it and couple of renders isn't good. You have to make it dynamic and you have put depth and flow into. A static signature is boring and it doesn't draw the eye. You add depth through creative blurring and sharpening. Stuff really far back and stuff really close up blurs. Things in the middle ground are sharp and in focus. Next is colors. You color choice is horrendous. The neons don't work if they're matte and look flat. You have to add a sheen and shine to it to give the neon look. Materials are like 50% of a C4D sig and the other important part is lighting. Having an excellent lighting set-up will give a certain crispness to the text. On the caps it will add a white reflection that will make the text look nice and sharp. Next glow should be used very sparingly. It looks unprofessional and really tacky.

TBH I didnt really go for the neon effect it just looks like it with the glow and colours. As for the colours they way the colours that the other people picked as for the dynamic-ness they wanted it to be flat as for mine i couldnt really care less and the lighting I am working on a new stage in c4d thanks for expressing your view but remember im just a beginner

High beginner.



You sir, aren't incredibly perceptive - read the original post and stop insulting fellow enthusiasts.

I was hoping for somewhere near high beginner to middle level TBH as that is really all what i am atm ive only just started on gfx and never done it before so thanks

 

[T R 1 B A L]

I was hoping for somewhere near high beginner to middle level TBH as that is really all what i am atm ive only just started on gfx and never done it before so thanks

It's completely subjective what you are - though in attempts at making a standardised classing system, the general categories generally go beginner, novice, moderate, intermediate, semi-pro and then pro.

 

[Barratt]

It's completely subjective what you are - though in attempts at making a standardised classing system, the general categories generally go beginner, novice, moderate, intermediate, semi-pro and then pro.

Okay, Wasn't really that bothered about what I put TBH I just wanted people to see it and then tell me what they thought about it but if I create a new thread i'll be sure to put: Beginner, Novice, Moderate, Intermediate, Semi-pro and Pro. Instead of Beginner, Medium, Semi, Pro.

 

[skipjack]

I second what Emperor_Nero said. This is very BASIC and man do I emphasize the word basic in this situation.

 

[MrLuckyDraw]

Beginner.

All of these are/look pretty basic. Looking up youtube videos would really help you here.

 

[Barratt]

Beginner.

All of these are/look pretty basic. Looking up youtube videos would really help you here.

Meh okay could you link some of the ones you think would benefit me most? I dont really like hunting for videos

 

[MohtasaUnique]

Beginner, very basic and boring. Also, professional is someone who is paid consistently for their graphics. No one on sythe really qualifies as professional. Kinaesthic is the closest we got, and you're no where near his level (and I still think some of his stuff is ugly, but that's probably because I despise 3D username signatures)

Www.tutorialized.com is a good place to start for tutorials.

 

[DeFyGFX]

Funny how these guys gonna try argue with nero lol
Next don't ask for critique if you can't take it.
If you want critique, why insult those who tell you the truth.

OT : Beginner - The text is pretty basic and looks like not much time has been put into the textures. Also the colours don't match that well on the 'Nathan' one.
I suggest looking online and searching for some tutorials on Lighting for C4D as they are what give your text nice reflections and shadows etc.
Heres one from TrooperFX - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KyHIjT-b5M8&feature=plcp

 

[Evilbobman]

Beginner, very basic and boring. Also, professional is someone who is paid consistently for their graphics. No one on sythe really qualifies as professional. Kinaesthic is the closest we got, and you're no where near his level (and I still think some of his stuff is ugly, but that's probably because I despise 3D username signatures)

Www.tutorialized.com is a good place to start for tutorials.

This pretty much sums up my opinion.

As of right now, everything is beginner.

 

[blitzduck]

Novice.

 

[Barratt]

Funny how these guys gonna try argue with nero lol
Next don't ask for critique if you can't take it.
If you want critique, why insult those who tell you the truth.

OT : Beginner - The text is pretty basic and looks like not much time has been put into the textures. Also the colours don't match that well on the 'Nathan' one.
I suggest looking online and searching for some tutorials on Lighting for C4D as they are what give your text nice reflections and shadows etc.
Heres one from TrooperFX - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KyHIjT-b5M8&feature=plcp

Thanks for the link i'll check it out soon and i havent seen nero's work but ive seen him around sythe i bet his work is good though =3. As for the colours i didnt pick them :/.

This pretty much sums up my opinion.

As of right now, everything is beginner.

Yeah I suppose it is

Novice.

Thanks for rating

 

[Issra]

Beginner. Nero was being excessive with the "Pre"

 

[Rockerr]

If you're gonna put beginner as an option and not accept it, don't ask for a rate at all.

This stuff is beginner to medium at most, the C4D work being medium and PS work being beginner. Like Nero mentioned all of your techniques can be learned from 1-2; 10 minute tutorials.

 

[Wrote_Murder]

All you do is talk shit about other peoples graphics, and act like you know everything about graphics there is to know, and hey maybe you do, I haven't even seen any of your work. But instead of saying that it's shit, maybe tell them how they could make it better.

OT: definitely have a lot to learn. work on the lighting, are you using c4d?

I don't even do GFX, and I could make better sigs, using the tutorials I watched in the past. Don't give up, all you need is a want, and it will come.

beginner.

Also, Nero is boss as fuck, so gtfo him.

 

[Barratt]

Beginner. Nero was being excessive with the "Pre"

TBH you cannot have a pre beginner :L because ive already begun

If you're gonna put beginner as an option and not accept it, don't ask for a rate at all.

This stuff is beginner to medium at most, the C4D work being medium and PS work being beginner. Like Nero mentioned all of your techniques can be learned from 1-2; 10 minute tutorials.

Wtf are you on about? I never said i didnt accept it. i accept all opinions and as i said before i havent watched any tutorials yet i havent had the time to ill look at some tomorrow maybe.

I don't even do GFX, and I could make better sigs, using the tutorials I watched in the past. Don't give up, all you need is a want, and it will come.

beginner.

Also, Nero is boss as fuck, so gtfo him.

Thanks for rating nothing else i can really put here :L

 

[MohtasaUnique]

I'm going to go ahead and lock this. You got your answer, nothing new can be said