Which Skill Is Better

[Philophrosyne]

For profit:


Fishing at level 85\90 living rock caverns

Woodcutting @ level 99 Magics or Yews

 

[Ecstasy Pker]

Im pretty sure level 90 Fishing at LRC is most profit.

 

LRC Rock tails ~200k p/h profit (when i was there a few months ago)

Magic logs ~ 170k p/h

 

[glamazonia]

As Jack pointed out, there isn't too much of a difference, so I'd just say to go with whichever you like more.

 

[sm321]

LRC Rock tails ~200k p/h profit (when i was there a few months ago)

Magic logs ~ 170k p/h

With rock Rock tails, doesn't your bait have a chance to be infected or something? So that would mean you can collect less = less money. I believe there's something you can complete/wear to stop it happening thought. I would say logs, as people are buying logs to use on bonfires.

 

[sotwnoz]

If you want do to woodcutting, I would not say yews, I would say Magic. Actually, 1 Magic Log has the worth of 3 yews, and I think Magic is just 2x slower or something, so do Magic, not Yews. Another thing to do is cutting normal logs. 1 Magic log has the same worth has 12 normal logs, but normal logs is so fast to cut, when you are 99, so it would maybe make you around 250k/hr. But I am not sure.

 

[Lyk2DG]

You should disreguard profit when skilling, I wouldnt bother cutting magics or yew trees since their horrible exp/h compared to ivy which requires the same amount of attention. (obviously you would be cutting pine if attention wasent an issue.)

Rocktails are decent amount of exp/h with granite lobster and an aura which is definaty worth investing in if you are going to be fishing rocktails you can max at about 117k exp/h with a t4 call of seas aura which is about 1m~ gp/h. (Again if attention isnt an issue then you should be c2 fishing or barbarian fly fishing its also not worth buying call of seas aura.)

 

With rock Rock tails, doesn't your bait have a chance to be infected or something?

Not unless there has been an update since the last time I went fishing that altered it since a month ago.

Personally I'd say do the fishing since they're practically the same, but this way you will work your way towards another 99 and it is faster experience

 

[GodGenesis]

Fishing rocktails would be the best for profit/hr if you ask me.

I personally got my first 100m through rocktail fishing.

 

[SkyLights]

Fishing, Cutting magics is even slow at 99.

 

[Philophrosyne]

If you want do to woodcutting, I would not say yews, I would say Magic. Actually, 1 Magic Log has the worth of 3 yews, and I think Magic is just 2x slower or something, so do Magic, not Yews. Another thing to do is cutting normal logs. 1 Magic log has the same worth has 12 normal logs, but normal logs is so fast to cut, when you are 99, so it would maybe make you around 250k/hr. But I am not sure.

Can I get this verified? (normal log 250k hr )


Also, nobody saw the 85 in my post? I wanted to compare them both since I'm only at 85 fishing right now, so what about cavefish vs magics?

 

[sotwnoz]

Can I get this verified? (normal log 250k hr )


Also, nobody saw the 85 in my post? I wanted to compare them both since I'm only at 85 fishing right now, so what about cavefish vs magics?

220k-270k/hr. I don't have time to test, otherwise I would, but you can test and then please post your result here

 

[RS Prodigy]

probably fishing

 

[Neil Trades]

Fishing is quicker, Rocktails are very profitable.

 

[Philophrosyne]

220k-270k/hr. I don't have time to test, otherwise I would, but you can test and then please post your result here

You can earn 60,000 to 80,000 coins per hour chopping logs.

From Runescape Wiki. Maybe it doesn't take in account 99 WC, I might try to see anyways.

 

[Falmar]

Fishing is better than WC