Which sig is better?

[MAK3 1T RA1N]

OR

Tips are appreciated also.

 

[Nefarious]

The second one because the first looks like you just slapped a picture on top of a background and put two soft brush dots. Actually that is what it is pretty much... match the colors a bit! Try a gradient map... orange to dark pink might look good.

 

[MAK3 1T RA1N]

Alright, thanks for the tip.

 

[hm0ng]

The first one because it doesn't have little dewayne on it. Also, the soft brushes doesn't look that good. Maybe one on his bracelet. And is that Fabolous?

 

[T.G.I.Friday]

Personally, the second one.
The first signature looks like a C4D Background. Then you just slapped a render on top.
No flow, No style, colors don't match, Bad Border Btw.

Back ground looks good although.

 

[MAK3 1T RA1N]

Thanks for the tip guys.

 

[xxmaulerxx]

yeh the first one does not match at all but the second 1 is pretty good

 

[MAK3 1T RA1N]

Mauler, why would you post when you have no clue about what you are talking about?

Thanks for trying though I guess.

 

[Client]

i like your old one best(the second).
much more intense.

 

[Billyy]

I like the first one alot, but I'm going to have to say I'd prefer the second one. Those brush dots look out of place, or too much opacity, maybe if you turned down the opacity on those, they would be better, and on the second one, it has good flow, great lighting effects, and I like the text.

 

[MAK3 1T RA1N]

Thanks Billyy, yea I agree with the brush dots too.

 

[Jesse]

First one has better artist, bad background random blue glows but the second one actually flows even though Lil' Wayne SUCKS :/

 

[Clank]

The first one. The #2 has blue dots which are placed ever so randomly.

 

[Decisive]

The first one because I don't like Lil Wayne, though I don't really like any of the sigs because you used C4d's and C4d's don't really make a sig look any better.

 

[Dark_Summer]

The first one looks better. It has a feeling that you worked hard on it. The other one looks like u just threw some barf on the computer

 

[MAK3 1T RA1N]

Ah stop hating on Lil Wayne. He's the best and this is just rating signatures not Rappers.

 

[Jansen]

Neither of them are all that good, but the second one is better

the teal dots are extremely obnoxious on the first one :{

 

[T.G.I.Friday]

Ah stop hating on Lil Wayne. He's the best and this is just rating signatures not Rappers.

Lol?
Lil Wayne is an ignorant drug-addicted, rapper.
His lyrics are so obscene and don't even make sense.
Personally, i feel like an idiot reading,repeating his lyrics.

Lil Wayne isn't the best or even Near.
'Nuff said.

 

[Nefarious]

Lol?
Lil Wayne is an ignorant drug-addicted, rapper.
His lyrics are so obscene and don't even make sense.
Personally, i feel like an idiot reading,repeating his lyrics.

Lil Wayne isn't the best or even Near.
'Nuff said.

You're missing the point, this thread isn't "Which rapper is better?" it's "Which SIG is better?".

 

[MAK3 1T RA1N]

Thanks Jansen, but you didn't really tell me about what I should work on.

Also, I like Lil Wayne, I don't really care if you like them or not, it's not going to change my opinion.

The only reason why I used that background on the first one because it looked really good in my opinion and I kind of messed up on the blue dots because I thought it would flow with his blue shirt but it obviously didn't. I just didn't and don't have the time to do better.