What does everyone make of this?

[i am java]

Because I knew my thread would be locked or hidden soon enough on the RuneScape forums, I decided to post this here to see what everyone else thought.

Today I realized that there were 3 messages in my inbox, so I went to check them. 2 of them told me that offenses were made on my account. I went to the appeal offenses and the only other offense I found that hadn't been appealed was one back in March of 2008. (Yes, that's right, over a year ago.)

http://forum.runescape.com/forums.ws?14,15,79,58727088,goto,1

I submitted my appeal and low and behold less than a minute later (literally) my appeal is denied. The best evidence I could find to support Jagex's claim against my account is as follows:
____________________________________

feal_my_pure: 100m is nothing nowadays..
feal_my_pure: i havnt tried to make money in about a year and i still got about 60m
feal_my_pure: ok..
feal_my_pure: ladie
feal_my_pure: which website did u buy off of btw?
feal_my_pure: lol!
feal_my_pure: well i can tell
____________________________________

What rule is it that I broke? Rule 9: Encouraging others to break rules.

Is it just me, or did I get a black mark for accusing someone of buying their gold? If that's the case, 50,000 more black marks should be handed out due to people accusing others of real world trading - which I see all too often.

 

[C_Town_Hero]

hmm, well i can look at that from both prespectives like this.
*I know you werent telling him to buy gps*
but by you saying (where did you buy your gps from?) That makes the other person know that they can buy gps.
But from your side, you techinicaly didnt tell him to go buy gps.

 

[i am java]

hmm, well i can look at that from both prespectives like this.
*I know you werent telling him to buy gps*
but by you saying (where did you buy your gps from?) That makes the other person know that they can buy gps.
But from your side, you techinicaly didnt tell him to go buy gps.

I could ask the question "Are you beating your wife?" and that would mean that I am encouraging you to beat your wife? :S

Technically I didn't tell them to go buy their gold, I asked them where they bought it..

 

[Rhett3]

For this exact reason is why I don't talk about any form of breaking the rules EVER.

 

[Solidddd]

For this exact reason is why I don't talk about any form of breaking the rules EVER.

Exactly, it's a stupid offence but nothing you can do.

Keep black market talk to IRC.

 

[miscievious]

jagex have nothing better to do these days runescape is falling apart