We Need Some kind of feedback for users

MMA · Mar 16, 2013

We need some form of feedback for users where you can leave feedback for users weather it be negative or positive. Right know you only get to see users positive feedback which is vouches but we can't tell much from vouches. The reason why I'm saying this is I've dealt with "trusted users" who are a pain in the ass, rude, slow but why wouldn they care about any of that stuff if they don't have to worry about people leaving them negative feedback or anything of that sort. I could post on their thread but I'd probably get reported for spam and infracted.

Elena · Mar 16, 2013

We have a thread for feedback right here.

http://www.sythe.org/feedback/1378830-community-appreciation.html

MMA · Mar 16, 2013

Elena said:
We have a thread for feedback right here.

http://www.sythe.org/feedback/1378830-community-appreciation.html

I mean some king of feature that's linked to their account where people can just leave some kind of feedback, weather it just be posts on their profile or a feedback system. Will probably be dnied but I really do think we need something similar to player auctions.

Elena · Mar 16, 2013

Isn't that the same as a vouch basically? or are you saying for like doing a good job type thing?

Heeatz · Mar 16, 2013

It's not going to happen. has been suggested/denied SEVERAL times before..

symphony888 · Mar 16, 2013

It is gonna get denied anyway. The vouches system is good enough already.

MMA · Mar 16, 2013

Elena said:
Isn't that the same as a vouch basically? or are you saying for like doing a good job type thing?

I'm mainly thinking for people who don't do a good job.

Elena · Mar 16, 2013

Well, maybe we could have just another thread like community appreciation but for negative feedback?

MMA · Mar 16, 2013

Elena said:
Well, maybe we could have just another thread like community appreciation but for negative feedback?

But that's not going to effect them who gonna go look threw posts.

Elena · Mar 16, 2013

Well then It will probably be denied as to it is on the DSL located here.

http://www.sythe.org/suggestions/1445207-do-not-suggest-list-updated-15-july-2012-a.html

tMoon · Mar 16, 2013

Elena said:
Well then It will probably be denied as to it is on the DSL located here.

http://www.sythe.org/suggestions/1445207-do-not-suggest-list-updated-15-july-2012-a.html

^ Pretty much this.

I get what you're saying, right now the only way to really tell someone's trust is by vouches. Saying so, when someone receives negative feedback for something such as questing, that user isn't going to include that in their vouch page. It'll simple be shrugged off as something that "didn't happen."

Vouches is a one-sided system.

While it would be a good thing to implement into Sythe, there's no telling how hard it would be to implement such a feature.

Elena · Mar 16, 2013

^ well, That's why maybe a negative feedback thread like the community appreciation would work.

MMA · Mar 16, 2013

Elena said:
^ well, That's why maybe a negative feedback thread like the community appreciation would work.

That still wouldn't do much as far as effecting them.

Elena · Mar 16, 2013

It's better then nothing though in my opinion.

pray4plagues · Mar 16, 2013

It's a bias point of view in both cases initially, vouches only include positive feedback, and a feedback system is motioned toward as you say for negative feedback. Any negative feedback, if the user really feels the need to put it across can be posted - with evidence in the feedback section of the forums. I can't see it making all that much of a difference, that's why it has been denied previously. To implement such a thing and make it fair would be a near impossible task as it could so easily be abused and would create unnecessary amounts of work for the staff team. I understand the concept, it's just far too much hassle.