Right so the people you talk about: why would they bother with DNT? They can just ban evade and they do. Humans respond to incentives. Not all scam cases are black and white. Many are disputed contracts or sour relations. Think "X held gold for me and got hacked while holding it". Being completely shut out with no voice and no empathy on a black and white hard decision is completely alienating. If it happened to me I wouldn't want to come back. And again this has nothing to do with DNT. If they are going to ban evade they will do it regardless of the existence of the DNT system. I think it provides an avenue for victims to talk to the user who scammed them and arrange a repayment plan. People who ask for DNT are expressing an interest in rejoining the community. To slam the door in their face is not going to improve any outcome for anyone.