Trying 3d again

Trying some new methods and such. Any comments/criticism would be much appreciated!

 

Wow! really nice piece of work!

 

I think the background needs to be changed form the grunge-ness. The left flare should be removed and the one in the middle should be toned down because it is overpowering the sig.

On the good side - good color sense (Though the blue could be a touch darker), nice concept, really neat font.

 

Like the text, and colour scheme.
However, I'm not really liking the middle flare? Tone it down a bit? Really overpowers it.

On the whole though, great job

 

The criticism and comments are much appreciated. I'll try and fix the first one up asap.

Added a new one!

 

The textures/stocks you used on the second one are way too LQ.

 

i love the second one, it looks really good

 

I don't really like the second one, the blue and the smoke effect dont really blend, but id be interested in buying the 1st one

but on the 1st one try lessening the flare in the u it would look really really good then

 

I would agree I prefer the top one it has a nice effect and catches your eye, the second one it good but pesonally I would lose the smoke. Great work anyhows! Keep it up!

 

I like the top signature.

 

First is awesome for sure, great colours and effects. Good crisp text. Perhaps the light streak is a little overpowering though?

Second I don't like the colours, the background effects and the text which is too flat looking against the background.

 

Wow , really nice work I'll deffo want one made by you

 

2nd is much worse, in my opinion. The flame effect looks low-quality, and doesn't blend well.

Also, the text is verging on awful - maybe try reducing the brightness of the flames, and try putting them behind the text, and revert to the first text?
Also, I can't see what the far right letter is.

 

pretty awesome, for 3D I sometimes pile 2 different types of font, notice the brown at the back and the green at the front

 

I would like to add the comment. I like the top signature because it very visual and a very good colour that is match on signature. You did it excellent! Keep it up, buddy!

 

I think the first one has a really nice, fluid design. The background could be a little more sharp, though.

I simply don't like the 2nd one.

 

Top one would be good without the center light flare. Overall, nice job!

 

I like the first alot, the second need some colours to have changed. Can I ask you what program you are using to creat those Signatures? PM me please.

Thanks

 

i like the second one the most, but i dont see where your getting '3D' at in these signatures?

 

they are both amazing! nice work