The thing is, my theory behind the on and off punishments for macroing (constantly switching between temporary and permanent) is that Jagex are trying to gather as much information as they can on botters as to improve their detection system - once the permanent bans came BACK the first time, Lo behold! Huge Mass Bannings at popular botting locations! They bring the temps back in order to encourage botters to do their thing even more, heck I'm sure they'd love it if you suicided, as the data they can get from your working patterns would be used to ban you, and hundreds of others, later in the future