Pace is an accurate measurement. If you came up on him too fast, then it's his word against yours, and he'll win as he doesn't have to clock you going fast to know that you were going fast.
However, you can dispute the amount of speed, saying that his value could be incorrect, and there's no way to prove exactly how fast you were going, and therefore assigning an arbitrary number is impossible unless he knew the exact distance you were from him and timed how long it took for you to come up on him, then performed an mph check.
Feasible, indeed, but you could argue rough estimation with time and distance in this case, and try and go for a less hefty fine as 13 miles over is.
E: Given that he was doing 55, he would have to recalculate distance and time all the while driving. Especially at 10 o'clock at night. You could easily argue that you were only doing 5 over, and his calculation was way off.