Can I say, even though they are newcomers, they might have potential.
Just a little bit of advice when I first started idontbot.com and First Class Questing.
Start small. I chose a group of people with 20-30 vouches, and they're all very successful nowadays, and some with higher amounts. This is just a few I've worked with. (Superman - Mod, Frenzy - Mod, -Ryan - Mod, Dave - Mod, Verts - Admin)
I've only had three users get banned, Stui, Imagine and Smperfidelis. (Not bad to say I've worked with over 12 members!)
Freakyhair I took on with 12 vouches, and I still work with him to this very day, as well as having Delta Squad with low vouches. It's not what reputation they have, it's what reputation they can make. Just a thought for ya.