I took the original payment picture as a precaution, just in case he did scam me. I scrolled up again to take the picture of his paypal email, not realizing his paypal email was already in the original picture.
I'd like to know why the chat log isn't considered proof. It's not copied and pasted, it's an ACTUAL log of the MSN conversation, the timestamp for the messages all match the conversation (the last message, which I left out was at 8:11, and you can see in the log that the last message was at 8:11:10) you can even see that it's his email. Note the "Seal-Sythe" at the top in the address bar.