Both are great! I like the old look of runescape but I find classic looks too old but than again I
remember all the good times I had on classic and the newer version on runescape
I hate the current state of RuneScape, but I loved the 2005-06 version of the game. Unfortunately I started playing at the release of RS2, so I never really got into classic.
Runescape classic in my opinion was pretty lame, I tried it out and got bored of it really fast. Runescape has always been better than runescape classic.