I think if you're willing to put the time in, and you're actively open for swaps, eventually your name will be recognized by the customers. So yes, it's profitable.
It all depends on the leadership of the clan, and how often you are on. If you are on for only 2 hours a day, don't expect the same profits as someone on for 10 hours per day. As for the leadership, you'll want to look for a clan that has a solid core group of guys that are dedicated to keeping the clan running big, and running smooth. The reasoning for that is so that if/when you buy in, the clan doesn't crumble within just a couple weeks.
Lastly, with the decline in the number of players, unstable 07 market, and a number of other factors, swapping has become less of a profitable market. How profitable? I couldn't give you exact numbers, but it is no where the 500M+ RS3/day that it was capable of making near the beginning on OSRS. It is still profitable enough to be worth buying in, but do your research on clans before you buy in
I guess you should look at each of the clans swapping margins to as they may differ, this would/may result in more trades for one clan over the other? Just a thought.