I think most of the top games are console games tbh. I just voted RS for the hell of it though lol, I don't really play any other games except a little bit of RS. Never been a big gamer
League of legends, although the normal version is what some consider a 'spin-off' of DoTA dominion, runes, masteries and etc really just freshens it up enough to be a new and innovative game.
Aren't these all mmo's? I don't really like any of them. I think there's a bunch more that you should have considered.. I'm having a pretty good time with Skyrim right now, and BF3 is always fun.