This is seriously messed up that you lost man you should do some investigation as this isn't like $5 you can lose here and there =(
This is a very corrupted fucked up scammer though he basically did everything he or "she" could to get away with this.
Of course the police wouldnt give a rats ass about virtual goods as well with paypal so its a huge risk. Hope you can fix this problem some other way =(
and dont use paypal anymore or only with trusted people/player auctions
Im starting to hate paypal more now we should all find different ways to get paid now im gonna keep looking around...
That's a lot of money and highly worth filing a police report If I was you. Contact her via phone and notify her that you are in the process of filing a police report. The person might get scared and refund / give you the amount owed.