I got iBot lite, tried it, put it at chickens on a brand new account, a strength pure, it got 22 strength and ban. I appealed the account, got it back, and then started woodcutting. 49 woodcutting from one and ban, so I switched proxies an d then started a range pure, got 30 range by hand and then trained at rock crabs, got 65 range and ban, appealed, got it back, got 70 range by hand, then started getting 82 magic, got 45 by hand, botted to 78, and ban, the day membership ended. So, lite is 100% epic fail.
I got iBot pro, made a strength pure, brought it to chickens (using different proxy than above, this being a difference of a week) and got 50 strength, and got a temp. Then I got it 20 attack by hand, and brought it to cows and got 65 strength, took a break from botting for 2 days, started again but got 70 woodcutting with no problems, botting 7 hours a day, then started FMing the logs first thing, burned all those and bought the logs for 99 fming, botted 95 fming and then did the rest by hand, and took a 3 day break, went back to woodcutting, got 85 woodcutting no ban, got membership, got 40 attack by hand, then botted strength 65-70 strength at rock crabs, then trained range 1-70 at rock crabs, first thing, got a temp. After temp I got 1-70 magic by hand, then got 70-82 magic botting. Got 70-80 strength botting, took a 2 day break, got 40-60 hand, and got a temp after I finished MM. I switched proxies, then took a 2 day break, played on and off for 1-2 hours by hand for 3 days, then botted 1-80 fishing, then sold all the fish and got 99 cooking, all botting, and stopped. I then sold the account to gold4rs.
So, myself having so much success with iBot pro, I would have to recommend it, my top choices, in order, 1. iBot pro, 2. RID, 3. RSBot, or make your own using all of them. If you had the expierence I would say make you own, I had a friend who did that and botted an amazing maxed barrows pure with 5 99's, without a ban. Sounds pretty good.