MOTM Announcement.

[mumble]

Hello,

It has come to the attention of the Community Development Team, that the most recent MOTM winner, @Seraphic has not maintained the outstanding membership that got him to that position. It is in the interest of the CDT to have Members of the Month, leave a positive impression on the Sythe community. He has not. It is for this reason that we have decided to strip @Seraphic of his MOTM.

If you have any questions or comments regarding this decision please leave them below and we'll be happy to respond to them.

 

[Rose Gold]

juicy

 

I disagree, he won fair, although I don't understand how could people vote for him.

Fair competition regardless

EDIT: @Paper Shark made some good arguments on Discord. I now agree with the decision.

 

Unfortunate, really. But does the CDT team really mean it?

OT: Will there be some kind of recount so that the person who came 2nd can be awarded the MOTM?

 

[Paper Shark]

Unfortunate, really. But does the CDT team really mean it?

OT: Will there be some kind of recount so that the person who came 2nd can be awarded the MOTM?

No, for a couple of reasons but I don't see the need to go into that.

 

why you removing ranks from people now? Seraphic was the member of the month for the work he did that month. What he does after shouldn't really matter.

 

seraphic losing his MOTM is BS. He deserved it and the community teams voted for him. Give back his rank!

 

This makes no sense tbh and his award should stand. He demonstrated the behaviour that earned him the award during the month in question and didn't act out of line whilst in that period, so the sentiment of member of the 'month' is still completely valid. If a restaurant wins an award for having the best burger one year, then starts serving complete shit the next, do they get the previous year's award removed? No. This argument is about standards throughout a certain period of time and Seraphic delivered on that.

 

Yeah this is completely bs,
not just was the reason for Seraphic completely BS and unfair and unjust!
and now you are stripping him of him member the month for that particular month,
his behavior after that time period doesn't matter,

The CDT is bs, first they denied my application cold heartly and now they remove seraphic member of the month for unfair reasons , get your shit in order cdt

Edit:
@veng asked me to verify , this is a legit comment and not a troll post

 

seraphic losing his MOTM is BS. He deserved it and the community teams voted for him. Give back his rank! This makes no sense tbh and his award should stand. He demonstrated the behaviour that earned him the award during the month in question and didn't act out of line whilst in that period, so the sentiment of member of the 'month' is still completely valid. If a restaurant wins an award for having the best burger one year, then starts serving complete shit the next, do they get the previous year's award removed? No. This argument is about standards throughout a certain period of time and Seraphic delivered on that.


why you removing ranks from people now? Seraphic was the member of the month for the work he did that month. What he does after shouldn't really matter. The CDT is bs, first they denied my application cold heartly and now they remove seraphic member of the month for unfair reasons , get your shit in order cdt

 

[Eazy E]

DISCLAIMER: IDK why he did to deserve the stripping of the award but...

I agree that if he had gotten the award for his service at the time, then afterwards got banned or did something wrong, the award for the month that he won SHOULD STAND. If that's the case, then everyone who has been banned on sythe, who received a MOTM award before their ban, should have their award stripped. Period. The only fair. Do these people exist? Idk, but if they do they should get it removed

I think this is wrong. It's like saying that if Lebron was voted MVP for the 2014 season, and then in 2015 he killed someone, the team would strip his MVP award?

I know this isn't the best argument, but I don't see why someone can get striped of a pervious award for something that happened after the award was given. Why should someone who has been banned before get mod status? Should we striped all mods who had pervious bans of mod status?

Just a thought

 

[jackthehackm8]

I mean should a member of the month have a mini rank that shows they were super outstanding, only to be clicked on and be banned? I agree with the cdt on this part. If he wants it he can reform after his ban and become MOTM again

 

I mean should a member of the month have a mini rank that shows they were super outstanding, only to be clicked on and be banned? I agree with the cdt on this part. If he wants it he can reform after his ban and become MOTM again

Just read the examples above

If someone wins something for something they have done in a specific month their actions for the following months shouldn't matter.

 

[Rivenstarz]

why you removing ranks from people now? Seraphic was the member of the month for the work he did that month. What he does after shouldn't really matter.

This ^

 

Can't say I agree with this decision but what's done is done. Sorry Seraphic!

 

logging in to say this is fucking retarded

 

[Rose Gold]

i don’t agree with this fucking indian giving cdt. give it back to sera

 

[Eazy E]

I just can't see how this is right. I mean I don't see how MOTM has anything to do with the ban

If he got MOTM for one month, just let him have it

I would agree with this if he was banned for an account he sold or something his did during that Month, before he recieved the award.

Can someone please tell me why he was scammed? I have actually talked to him before over sythe and he seemed like a nice person I just would like to know why he was banned:/

Regardless, I Am in the dark on this obviously, but was removing a rank the best idea? Why not just make a formal statement about it and let the Ban be his punishment.

 

[Eazy E]

Wait so I just found out that he may have been banned for "disclosure of personal information". This has nothing to do with CDT MOTM..

Also, apparently according to him, he should not have gotten a ban since he stated "I found this information on sythe" and claims he only reposted the information.


If this is true, and he got a ban for this, I can get one of Sythe's BEST AND BIGGEST gold sellers who is actually a very very nice guy banned for 6 months since he quoted my IRL name on an unrelated thread.


Just trying to make that clear^


Please correct me if I'm wrong on this..

 

Lol, this is dumb as fuck. You could have done this quietly and discussed it with him if it was really such a big issue, but instead you decided to make an announcement about it. If he's MotM for X, what he does in Y should be irrelevant - If it's really serious then he'll be banned and it won't matter at all because you won't see him on Sythe.