• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

MiniRank price thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
No support on this, people come up with their own prices, finding a price and negotiating is part of the market.

Higher ups on this site should not be dictating(or guiding/implying) market prices.

Thus, no support.
 
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
Just for your convenience; all miniranks can be found via,
user center>perks>minirank directory *all miniranks displayed*

@Superfluous how would that help with prizeboxes etc; or awarded from events etc. as in rare miniranks not yet price known.
well you could scrape the minirank directory to keep things up to date

not sure what you'd want to do with prizeboxes. keep some log of how many of x minirank were opened?

and rare miniranks are like anything else - someone decides to pay $xx for them, and they get logged. obviously there's no price known before that happens.

side note - it would also be interesting if we could get info on the # of each minirank in existence. i think someone brought this up before and dont remember why it was turned down. oh well
 
Last edited:
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
No support on this, people come up with their own prices, finding a price and negotiating is part of the market.

Higher ups on this site should not be dictating(or guiding/implying) market prices.

Thus, no support.
its not dictating market prices if all prices are logged by users on their own volition, its providing information in a grey market to help people make informed choices.
 
its not dictating market prices if all prices are logged by users on their own volition, its providing information in a grey market to help people make informed choices.

Making informed choices in a market based setting regarding a market based item is part of the free market, that's why I've been able to merch people for $5 miniranks and sold miniranks at $50 each, that's part of the market.

Staff nor anyone else should be involved in dictating or preventing market practices, the market is meant to be a free market thus there should be no guide, no sticky, dictating or implying prices.

If people get merched $5 or $10 extra, that's part of the market, I know I have plenty of times.

You win some, you lose some, that's how the market is suppose to work.

Informed traders get the best deals(much like the stock market).

You wouldn't write a price guide for everybody on a stock trading forum would you?no.

This suggestion just babys all the uninformed traders.
 
Last edited:
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
ok and if someone wants to create a way to log prices using available information, i see nothing wrong with them doing that. its still a free market; its just more informed than it otherwise would have been, and prices more rapidly reach stable equilibria as a result. no one is dictating anything.
 
Last edited:
ok and if someone wants to create a way to log prices using available information, i see nothing wrong with them doing that. its still a free market; its just more informed than it otherwise would have been, and prices more rapidly reach stable equilibria as a result. no one is dictating anything.

I'd like to request someone non-staff then makes it(even if its CDT), Staff's involvement in the prices and the market should be as minimal as can be.

It should be a community made guide, not a staff made one.

Seems like a reasonable compromise to me, if that happens I wont mind as much.
 
Last edited:
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
I'd like to request someone non-staff then makes it(even if its CDT), Staff's involvement in the prices and the market should be as minimal as can be.

It should be a community made guide, not a staff made one.

Seems like a reasonable compromise to me, if that happens I wont mind as much.
op suggested it, not me! :p
 
Former OMM
Pool Shark
Detective
Two Factor Authentication User
Nitro Booster
In Memory of Jon
Rio 2016
Community Participant
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
It's like saying every maxed RS account should be worth X amount of dollars. It's a matter of what you see the in the minirank that is of value to you. No support.
 
In Memory of Jon
Gohan has AIDS
Pokémon Trainer
Poképedia
I have quite a bit of experience in the minirank market. I can probably just make an unofficial price guide of my own opinion and post that thread in the sandbox. It won't be stickied but it can be bumped as much as possible and linked to.
 
Average prices or a price range based on rarity / what they go for sure, however keep in mind there is no set value and prices are largely just dependent on what people are willing to pay for them.
 
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
Users should be buying/selling for what they think the value of the minirank is worth to them, not by following a price listing. Most miniranks aren't even in circulation, so whoever makes the price listing thread would be making up their own prices along the way.
not directly solely at you, but i think people are just reading the first post and not the rest of the thread. yes, obviously some guy saying "this minirank is worth x!" isn't useful, but i think my suggestion gets around that (ie, make this "guide" a running list of all user-reported transaction prices... maybe better called a "log")
 
ok and if someone wants to create a way to log prices using available information, i see nothing wrong with them doing that. its still a free market; its just more informed than it otherwise would have been, and prices more rapidly reach stable equilibria as a result. no one is dictating anything.

Contradicting yourself here. You say prices would reach a stable price as a result of this log, thus decisively affecting the price of miniranks. This would be dictating prices.
 
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
Contradicting yourself here. You say prices would reach a stable price as a result of this log, thus decisively affecting the price of miniranks. This would be dictating prices.
no, it would be telling people "the last x trades occurred at a, b, c, d, and e prices - use that information to determine what you want to pay" not "trades outside that range are not allowed."

there's always going to be a fine line between reporting prices and manipulating prices. the point of my addition to op's suggestion is that prices would be reported accurately and as completely as possible, in the sense that we would try to reach all parties in all minirank transactions and have them, not some arbitrary person given authoritative power over this process, keep track of things. this information would be voluntarily made public by the parties involved, and therefore i see no reason why it couldnt be aggregated somewhere.
 
no, it would be telling people "the last x trades occurred at a, b, c, d, and e prices - use that information to determine what you want to pay" not "trades outside that range are not allowed."

there's always going to be a fine line between reporting prices and manipulating prices. the point of my addition to op's suggestion is that prices would be reported accurately and as completely as possible, in the sense that we would try to reach all parties in all minirank transactions and have them, not some arbitrary person given authoritative power over this process, keep track of things. this information would be voluntarily made public by the parties involved, and therefore i see no reason why it couldnt be aggregated somewhere.

Dictate - control or decisively affect; determine.

Why should this only be a thing for miniranks? Surely this could be done for every market, don't you agree?
 
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
Dictate - control or decisively affect; determine.

Why should this only be a thing for miniranks? Surely this could be done for every market, don't you agree?
if people are willing to publicly contribute information and there's an unbiased process for collecting it, then yeah, why not.

most markets wouldnt benefit much from this because there's a lot of good information out there... eg if gold is being sold for $1.00 - 1.10 then the price people are willing to pay is probably somewhere in that range. the trouble with miniranks is that that information doesn't exist, so this would be a way of coming up with that information. also op only mentioned this for miniranks so that's why the conversation is focused on them
 
if people are willing to publicly contribute information and there's an unbiased process for collecting it, then yeah, why not.

most markets wouldnt benefit much from this because there's a lot of good information out there... eg if gold is being sold for $1.00 - 1.10 then the price people are willing to pay is probably somewhere in that range. the trouble with miniranks is that that information doesn't exist, so this would be a way of coming up with that information. also op only mentioned this for miniranks so that's why the conversation is focused on them

Why do you think that information does not exist?
 
Why do you think that information does not exist?
It doesn't. New players have no idea what the GENERAL PRICE RANGE of miniranks are. The idea here is to give a guide on what miniranks go for I think you're completely looking at it wrong. This is by no means a set price for a minirank. If the average price for a rupee is $30 that's just informing newer players what general price to have in mind. You can still sell or by for whatever you want.. This will create a lot more trading due to people that were unaware of prices having more knowledge of what they are actually paying for.
With gold prices being a way more active market you can go look through threads and know a good range of what to pay within 2 minutes. With miniranks you wouldn't know because there is such a large variety of them. For example buying a more rare rank such as ninja. You don't see that one traded you can't just look through threads and know what to expect.. Ultimately what you buy or sell a minirank for is up to you. I believe this reference guide would just help bring in more traders.
 
It doesn't. New players have no idea what the GENERAL PRICE RANGE of miniranks are. The idea here is to give a guide on what miniranks go for I think you're completely looking at it wrong. This is by no means a set price for a minirank. If the average price for a rupee is $30 that's just informing newer players what general price to have in mind. You can still sell or by for whatever you want.. This will create a lot more trading due to people that were unaware of prices having more knowledge of what they are actually paying for.
With gold prices being a way more active market you can go look through threads and know a good range of what to pay within 2 minutes. With miniranks you wouldn't know because there is such a large variety of them. For example buying a more rare rank such as ninja. You don't see that one traded you can't just look through threads and know what to expect.. Ultimately what you buy or sell a minirank for is up to you. I believe this reference guide would just help bring in more traders.

You're confusing the question. I'm asking why do you think this information does not exist. I'm not questioning the existence of set prices. The reason for this is that the minirank market is a strategic market.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top