I'm no artist, but I prefer number two. In my opinion though.. If you brought the aspect ratio in on 2. Bringing your focus on the key and the text at the bottom it would look a lot better. Also a better quality image would come in handy.
The second is better, but both are pretty bad.
I literally cannot focus on the car keys, even if I try. The text should be secondary to the image, but currently it's the only part I can look at.