To the people saying use "All tokens", from the picture, it looks like he's a zerker. And to get all the different tokens, he would have to gain defence exp.
Well it's not a complete loss. Warriors guild is always insane experience, and you'll eventually get it. I always go for around 3 trips which is usually 5-10 defenders, depending on my luck.
I use obby shields now lol, cbf getting 50+ of them for pking. Do you still need to get a crap load of tokens or have they changed it? It looks completely different now :O