Xanti-Xhero
Active Member
Simple question : Do you think the United States should return to it's Isolationist style of a nation, or continue Capitalism?
Isolationist or Capitalist?
- Thread starter Xanti-Xhero
- Start date
Juicy Juice
Active Member
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2009
- Sythe Gold
- 0
- Messages
- 101
What he said. Isolationist is a type of foreign policy. Capitalist is a type of economic policy. The only thing "Isolationistic Capitalism" brings to mind is that time when Thomas Jefferson closed off the American Economy to Europe.
We didn't do so well, lol!
I'll answer both questions though, if you'll let me.
1. In terms of foreign policy, no, I do not think we should be isolationists. It might've worked in 1800, but we weren't a world power then. We are now. One of two superpowers. To the majority of the world, we are the ONLY superpower. What we say goes. And, though overstated and quite cheesy, "With great power comes great responsibility". We need to set an example. Everybody looks to us. Yeah, they criticize us when we mess up, but they still need us. We need to be the leaders, the role models. How can we possibly expect any other country to act respectably if we are unwilling to do it ourselves? We can't shrug off the entire world. We depend on THEM as much as they depend on US.
As for capitalism, yeah, supply and demand seems to be the best way to make things work. However, pure capitalism, as proven in the past, is bogus. Regulation is important. Not full fledged socialism, but making sure that business play fair, that the meat isn't poisoned, etc is important.
We didn't do so well, lol!
I'll answer both questions though, if you'll let me.
1. In terms of foreign policy, no, I do not think we should be isolationists. It might've worked in 1800, but we weren't a world power then. We are now. One of two superpowers. To the majority of the world, we are the ONLY superpower. What we say goes. And, though overstated and quite cheesy, "With great power comes great responsibility". We need to set an example. Everybody looks to us. Yeah, they criticize us when we mess up, but they still need us. We need to be the leaders, the role models. How can we possibly expect any other country to act respectably if we are unwilling to do it ourselves? We can't shrug off the entire world. We depend on THEM as much as they depend on US.
As for capitalism, yeah, supply and demand seems to be the best way to make things work. However, pure capitalism, as proven in the past, is bogus. Regulation is important. Not full fledged socialism, but making sure that business play fair, that the meat isn't poisoned, etc is important.
DropKick Murphys
Guru
- Joined
- Mar 26, 2007
- Sythe Gold
- 0
- Messages
- 1,837
Isolationism is a terrible idea - it decreases trade and thereby decreases wealth productions. More globalization is what we need, with less intervention in other places affairs and no interference in markets and low or no taxes.
DropKick Murphys
Guru
- Joined
- Mar 26, 2007
- Sythe Gold
- 0
- Messages
- 1,837
That's a great quote, I haven't heard it in awhile either.
Juicy Juice
Active Member
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2009
- Sythe Gold
- 0
- Messages
- 101
It's unrealistic in the 21st century. In 1800 we were nobodies. Communication was done through letters. We didn't even have the telegraph until 1837. It took ships weeks to travel across the atlantic. We felt like we could be isolated from Europe politically because we were isolated from them geographically--an idea Jefferson took to heart. He wanted our nation to be a nation of farmers.
In a post modern world where information travels as fast as it's presented, we need allies.
In a post modern world where information travels as fast as it's presented, we need allies.