I got infracted for false spam.

[mike_w_99]

Well basically, I got infracted for Spamming. This infraction is unfair because I posted what I thought about his video, as well as alot of videos with hotkey usage. I posted garbage, nice hotkeys. It was my honest opinion, nobody else posted similar, so why did I get infracted for spamming? I think it should be removed.

Here is the thread: http://www.sythe.org/showthread.php?p=4708730#post4708730

 

[Tgump]

After lengthily discussing this with you on MSN, I've come to the conclusion that:

1) You were either spamming or just didn't care enough to give constructive feedback
2) Now that you were infracted, you're trying to bend the rules to get yourself out of an infraction.
3) Because of this, I urge you to rethink your posts and give constructive feedback in the future.

Second opinions welcome.

 

[mike_w_99]

You were either spamming or just didn't care enough to give constructive feedback

I wasn't exactly spamming as I thought stating the video was garbage, and saying nice hotkeys would influence people to believe that I didn't like it because of the hotkeys. ( Sarcasm )

Now that you were infracted, you're trying to bend the rules to get yourself out of an infraction.

Not trying to bend the rules rather than make a sarcastic statement as to what should be removed from his video to make it better.

Because of this, I urge you to rethink your posts and give constructive feedback in the future.

Definatley will.

 

[Tgump]

I wasn't exactly spamming as I thought stating the video was garbage, and saying nice hotkeys would influence people to believe that I didn't like it because of the hotkeys. ( Sarcasm )

It wasn't hard to say "I don't like your video, X is how to improve it. You might want to work on Y too." rather than "lol dis vid suks nice hotkeys"

 

[Jesse]

Garbage. Nice hotkeys, epic fail.

How is that not spam? That section is there to rate people and critique people; and saying it sucks and it fails is definitely not a rating. You could have spent 10 seconds more and typed up a small critique. "It's not very good because of __________ but you could have done ___________".

You were given a fair infraction. Denied.