Perhaps it would be better to have a verification requirement, and boost up the number of guide verifiers to more than just a few staff/trusted members.
If people who are trusted in that section, or in general, and are willing to verify a few guides it would clean out the crap guides, still be efficient (as long as there is enough people) and allow people to get a guaranteed non-biased review on a guide before buying.
Doing this may require a bit of a wait before selling guides, but it would make the guide section practically 100% scam/spam proof.
I only recently joined up to another Runescape cheating forum, even though i am fairly experienced/trusted on quite a few, and i was unable to get any trades due to my low post count. Low post count doesn't necessarily mean untrustworthy and bad quality, and if there was an improved verification/review system it would allow for people to become trusted.