• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

First & Second Signature!

Runflat

Forum Addict

Banned
Joined
Mar 29, 2011
Sythe Gold
0
Messages
523
Location
Belgium
Hi guys, started photoshop today and made 2 signatures. If you guys could rate them, thanks! I am giving these away too if actually someone wants them. Haha :)

#1
2lym87.png


#2
2urkvvo.png
 
Very nice firsts.

I don't really like the color scheme in the Spiderman background kind of clashes with Spiderman IMO.

The Assassin's Creed one on the other hand looks great.
 
STEVE
Lawrence
Heidy
Two Factor Authentication User
Pretty decent for first ones.
I presonally don't like any signature that has one base picture though.
But yeah, well everyone has their own taste. ^,^
 
There nice, but too basic.
 

This is constructive critisism, please don't take this as rude/disrespectful.
(I am also keeping in mind it's your first 2 sigs)

#1
The blending is actially not too bad, but the background is so flat behind him, it really fucks up the depth of it all, and makes for a kind of boring piece.

I'd recommend making alot more of the colors blend farther into the signature, watch/look at a bunch of smudging tutorials.

#2
The stocks seems very stretched horizontally, and it definitely shows.
I don't know if u planned it, but the light from the side versus the light against his robe are matched perfectly, adding for great depth in the piece

I'd recommend the same type thing, a little more background to render/stock blending as an image on a background with a little blur smudge doesn't make for an effectively smooth piece

All and all I'd give it 6.5/10 for your pieces, kudos.
 
Thanks for the feedback! Tried another one...

a4ophw.png

I really like this one- A lot better then the other two in my opinion.

I didn't like the colors in the first one but I did like the assassins creed one.
 
Thanks for the feedback! Tried another one...

a4ophw.png

My comments still stand from before, the focus sticks way off the page like u just pasted him onto a background, try blending, A LOT more, like almost overkill til u get used to it, then find a happy medium.
 
Runescape Gamblingrunescape gambling
Back
Top