Extra Loyalty points instead of Exp?

I was wondering what your opinions are on the idea suggested in this thread http://services.runescape.com/m=forum/c=ZftRFc8kIjQ/sl=0/forums.ws?15,16,803,63115876,goto,1 .

I personally feel that the idea suggested in that thread is better than what Jagex currently has, although I have a feeling most sythers would like bonus exp over more loyalty points.

 

I'm personally not interested in the loyalty points. Although that 10% bonus really isn't that much..

 

I'd prefer Loyalty points over just 10%.

10% wouldn't really get me to train more than normally, on the bonus exp weekends I always quitted at 1.5x..
If It'd give like 3k loyalty points i'd sure do it.

 

I think they should be giving loyalty points instead, an xp bonus is just going to get abused terribly. Loyalty points are a good incentive yet not as likely to be abused as something as important as xp.