Durial vs. TDD - Round 2 - Hellgate

[TDD]

post Who You Vote For And Why!

Stock used:

 

[sUffer]

Number one, simply because the effects are far superior.

 

[TidyBoi]

Top one gets my vote. Superior depth and flow. Nice simple effects also.

 

[Atomic]

The top is far superior.

 

[Pur3 5kiler]

2nd one. Simply because i like bright sigs.

 

[Vision Ex]

I voted for the top user. My reasoning is simple; the second user described what he tried to create to me, and was obviously far from what he wished. The top user got what he was looking for, and did well in editing his render, without visible error.

 

[Bbri06]

I voted for the top user because of mainly the lighting. In the bottom the lighting seems like it doesn't fit to me and that it covers to much of his arm. I also like the blue tint in the top one's lighting.

 

[WoW Sucks]

I vote for the bottom one, because i prefer it

 

[The Devils Son]

Well TDD's is still better than Duri's no matter what!

If you were smart enough u would know who's is who's.

The flow and style simply falls into place and theme is properly matched. Text is no to bad but still follows the theme. And again I like TDD's use of the monster's head being placed into the sig and looks like it is supposed to be there.

 

[Phil]

I vote the too one, i don't know who's it is again lol.

The blue glow is a really nice effect. The text is better, and it has more flow and depth, well done whoever's it is.

 

[Vision Ex]

Well TDD's is still better than Duri's no matter what!

If you were smart enough u would know who's is who's.

The point was to give them annonimity, so that no one votes for someone based on who created it.

 

[Steph]

The top one seems far better than the other.

 

[sKull]

Top one owns. <3 I think it's the one from durial. Soz, durial is much better.

 

[Xjaa]

The top one is Durials, same as the last one great depth and the blurred background is much nicer than the hard other

 

[Fat_Al]

top one simply cause its better

 

[Thebombdotorg]

top, though i don't particularly like the text, the actual gfx are a lot better.

 

[theprof22]

i like the text on the top one

 

[Conman3030]

Top gets my vote, the bottom looks like there were brushes involved or so I think. It doesn't work for me..

 

[Solid tank]

Top one. Greater lighting, text, depth, and effects. Simple.

Well TDD's is still better than Duri's no matter what!

IDIOT, the point of them not posting names was for the fact that you couldn't chose popularity..

 

[T7 Press 7T]

Really like the top one and how they separated the text with the cliping from each other, what throws me off is the lighting placement >.>