I like them all personally... But honestly i would prefer your suggestions over anything... I think you have some good ideas here... so keep up the good work ;-)
As I said earlier, I think that these are a good improvement over the current ones.
I've seen quite a few people say that they would donate more but they don't like the icon. Why not give the option to switch between the old ones and the new ones?
I don't understand why people don't like the newer ranks. Who cares, you donated to help Sythe. The icons you receive doesn't change how much you've donated, and if you think it looks cheap, you're pathetic.
I do like the new 5$ one. and I like what you did with the cash piles..however the switching around you did for Dclaws and h'ween masks I have to disagree with.