To get your account back, you'll need the email adress you registered with.
If the email you registered it with got keylogged aswell, I'd say GF. Inform a moderator and they can check all the IP-adresses that had access to "senatorjoe". If the IP-adress that first accessed "senatorjoe" is the same as the one currently on "senatorjoe2" AND the IP-adress that currently accesses "senatorjoe" differs from the previous "senatorjoe" IP-adresses, you're story makes perfect sense.
So that way, they can easily verify your story or banhammer you if you made this all up.
Good luck getting your account back.