Do not allow essay/assignment writing services.

[Hilary :)]

Hey all. The point of this thread is to try to convince you to disallow services for essays and other assignments. You may see the whole thing as providing a nice, clean service to other users, but in reality it is grade A academic plagiarism. Now, I'm not one of those pseudo-intellectuals claiming that fabricating school marks is immoral in the act itself, as I take the whole high school thing pretty lightly; however, the practical immorality of plagiarism is that - by your inflated marks - you may take the place of another more talented and willed individual when applying to a university, as his grade simply cannot stand up to that of a professional service. Is that really fair?

What I suggest you do: As a compromise, I suggest you do not allow full essays and assignments being written, but do allow essay and assignment help--and this can be in the form of services. This would be similar to a tutor.

Anyone agree?

 

[w000t]

It's there choice. It isn't plagiarism if they sold them the usage rights.

no support, sorry.

 

People take the place of more talented individuals all the time; it's called a racial quota, all universities do it. Is that really fair?

No support.

 

[Mr Smith]

If you needed an 10k word essay or something like that and you had NO idea how to do it, what would you do? I would use someone on here, but that is just my opinion. I think that they are doing good helping people who need help with their homework. No support, sorry.

 

[Hilary :)]

People take the place of more talented individuals all the time; it's called a racial quota, all universities do it. Is that really fair?

No support.

People are taking steps to getting rid of that, and are you saying you'd like to further erode the system just because it already has certain flaws? Is that very rational?

It's there choice. It isn't plagiarism if they sold them the usage rights.

no support, sorry.

Yes it is. Do you know what plagiarism is? And did you completely ignore the consequences I outlined in my post?

If you needed an 10k word essay or something like that and you had NO idea how to do it, what would you do? I would use someone on here, but that is just my opinion. I think that they are doing good helping people who need help with their homework. No support, sorry.

You would get a tutor or a mentor to help you. How would you feel if you destroy someone's chance at university? Look beyond the immediate implications.

 

[Clashfan]

It isn't plagiarism if they sold them the usage rights.

Yes it is. If you take the work of someone else and hand it in as your own, it's plagiarism.

That said, I don't necessarily think that it should be disallowed.

 

[Hilary :)]

Yes it is. If you take the work of someone else and hand it in as your own, it's plagiarism.

That said, I don't necessarily think that it should be disallowed.

Alright. Well, thanks for your input.

 

[Hilary :)]

Any other opinions?

 

[Sanctuary]

however, the practical immorality of plagiarism is that - by your inflated marks - you may take the place of another more talented and willed individual when applying to a university, as his grade simply cannot stand up to that of a professional service.

I completely agree with this, although, It really depends on the type of paper being written. Maybe disallow final or term papers to be written, and only helped?

 

[Hilary :)]

I completely agree with this, although, It really depends on the type of paper being written. Maybe disallow final or term papers to be written, and only helped?

I suppose that would be a start, but it still contributes greatly to your overall average.

 

[i noob killer i]

Go away slag . Its fine as it is . If you don't like it don't do? Standard

 

[rs obsidian]

If someone is happy to pay for an essay and someone is happy to write the essay for the agreed amount I don't see a problem other than the morality of it. No support.

 

[Hilary :)]

Go away slag . Its fine as it is . If you don't like it don't do? Standard

An unintellectual argument calls for an unintellectual response: You're an idiot.

If someone is happy to pay for an essay and someone is happy to write the essay for the agreed amount I don't see a problem other than the morality of it. No support.

This is the exact problem I was addressing....If you don't think acting immorally is wrong, well, that's very bad.

 

This is the exact problem I was addressing....If you don't think acting immorally is wrong, well, that's very bad.

Why give us a lecture on morality when we don't really care? That's all well and good that you do not want to cheat, that's your perogative. Don't take part in it. If you're so against cheating then you really shouldn't be on this site to begin with.

 

[DtheK]

Personally I've always thought that they were wrong...

Support.

 

[redawsomeness]

No support, it's their paper they can sell it. No matter what type of content it is, it's basically like selling a guide if you think about it, except the person buying is turning it in as their own work.

 

The following post is from Finally_Found_Freedom(OP) via msn.

Why give us a lecture on morality when we don't really care? That's all well and good that you do not want to cheat, that's your perogative. Don't take part in it. If you're so against cheating then you really shouldn't be on this site to begin with.

"This is a RUNESCAPE market site. Real world trading on a virtual game which does not exist indepently of the computer is hardly immoral."

No support, it's their paper they can sell it. No matter what type of content it is, it's basically like selling a guide if you think about it, except the person buying is turning it in as their own work.

"If you actually read my original post, I clearly identified that it is quite different than a regular market trade, as its implications stretch much further, and disadvantage people uninvolved with the trade for no fair reason."

 

If you want to take the risk then go for it. No one is forcing you to use anyones services.

 

[The Legit Shop]

no support. I see no valid point in not allowing it besides the fact that its immoral to some people.

 

Also from OP

If you want to take the risk then go for it. No one is forcing you to use anyones services.

Did you even read my thread, man?

no support. I see no valid point in not allowing it besides the fact that its immoral to some people.

Oh, because acting immorally to people shouldn't be considered. Do you know what the definition of a democracy is?