• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Disagree with this ruling

In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
If you ask me, those who are getting hacked are the ones who should have the knowledge on how to keep their accounts safe, as they've (for the most part) been here for quite a while. People have been getting hacked through creation/linked e-mails ever since I've been here, yet people still seem to create their public IM accounts with public e-mails.

People are being hacked just by name, location and some skype contacts. Whether they have private emails or not.
 
In my opinion, we should. They were stupid enough to not get verification before a trade when we preach every day, "GET A PM!"

We have multitudes of guides out there. Stickies with massive amounts of information in regards to safe trading practices. And plenty of experienced users that can give insight to the new users IF THEY TOOK THE TIME TO EVEN ASK.

It's not our fault, nor the victim of the hacked skype that these people are too goddamn lazy and incompetent to follow safe trading practices, and we shouldn't reward their stupidity.

What does sythe.org do to make these rules or "trading practices" what ever you wanna call them, known to new users. They have to go and search the site for some sticky. I've personally never seen one of the stickies you mention . I'm sure they exist but who's reading them? If you're all of a sudden not going to hold people responsible for their accounts you need to make this information public knowledge. Not have it tucked away in a sticky that no one ever bothers looking at. This may seem like common sense to us but to someone who has never been involved in any kind of "black market" trading site most likely has no idea. Although I personally get pm's for every trade I do, I can see why you wouldn't get a pm if it was someone trusted that you've done successful trades with before and it turns out this one time they ended up hacked and your're fucked because you didn't request a pm.
 
UWotM8?
<3 n4n0
Oktoberfest 2013
Village Drunk
Shitting Rainbow
Potamus
Sythe Awards 2012 Winner
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
MushyMuncher
People are being hacked just by name, location and some skype contacts. Whether they have private emails or not.

Because people are dumb enough to keep making public skypes when they know that the hacking is still ongoing. Keep in mind if you make a new PUBLIC skype, the hacker now has your new creation date.

The bottom like here is, its nobody elses fault only your own that you're a target. You (generally speaking) choose to become big on the site knowing that in turn, people would be out to get you to try and make a few bucks. Its a risk everybody takes, but now it seems its something that nobody wants to pay the consequences for.

Its sickening that people are going to be scammed by people they thought they could trust (or their hackers) and not get a dime in return.
 
Heidy
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
People are being hacked just by name, location and some skype contacts. Whether they have private emails or not.

Again it's obvious that Skype has some serious security flaws, and that was obvious when the first 4 people were hacked and Richard announced about the mass hackings. There wasn't a 'Okay, guys there are some thing wrong with Skype you shouldn't use it and advise all trading partners to use another method' it was 'Okay, change your email to something private'

It isn't the victims faults and due to bad decision making, but we are now punishing those people who got scammed. JackGoff and I are close friends and I talk to Jack a lot. If I were going to trade him I wouldn't PM him because I trust that, unless there are obvious signs, he is still JackGoff. Also as Marrow mentioned a couple pages back, when trading with Chinese gold traders or even some of the large traders here who have websites you don't normally ask for a PM. It's hard to believe that the staff are trying to go back and say 'Oh, you've traded this guy 20 times and you trusted him but since he got hacked and you didn't get a PM you're just SOL.' They're safe trading practices in place, but after numerous trades with someone you generally aren't going to ask them for a PM. Also as many mentioned this is going to set up a dangerous system where you can fake a hacking and not be responsible. People have ALWAYS been responsible for their accounts, why you are changing it now is beyond me...

I don't see, even though numerous staffers have spoke out against this, changing any time soon.
 
Then change the rule to where it is a 50-50 liability. It falls on the buyer for not requesting a pm and then it falls on the seller for choosing to use skype still.
 
In Memory of Jon
<3 n4n0
Sythe Awards 2013 Winner
Sythe Awards 2014 Winner
Sythe Awards 2015 Winner
JackGoff and I are close friends and I talk to Jack a lot. If I were going to trade him I wouldn't PM him because I trust that, unless there are obvious signs, he is still JackGoff.

With hackings going on, nobody should assume anything.
 
St. Patrick's Day 2013
In my opinion, we should. They were stupid enough to not get verification before a trade when we preach every day, "GET A PM!"

We have multitudes of guides out there. Stickies with massive amounts of information in regards to safe trading practices. And plenty of experienced users that can give insight to the new users IF THEY TOOK THE TIME TO EVEN ASK.

It's not our fault, nor the victim of the hacked skype that these people are too goddamn lazy and incompetent to follow safe trading practices, and we shouldn't reward their stupidity.

I find nearly this whole statement outrageous.

How in the name of god is someone getting rewarded by getting what they are owed?

I am shocked that such a statement came from someone of authority on this site.
 
I find nearly this whole statement outrageous.

How in the name of god is someone getting rewarded by getting what they are owed?

I am shocked that such a statement came from someone of authority on this site.

Lol dont be so shocked! They think that seeing they post 100 times a day and have been on the fourms for so long that everyone knows and understands how scamers are on this site and think that it is common Knowledge to request a pm.When for new members that just join the site or have even been apart of sythe for awhile and just dont post much like my self dont know that you should request a pm for all trades. This is that one sided view bull shit.

So 70% of the time when someone new joins they are run off either by being scammed or harassed. So to get there money back from being scammed they start to think what that guy did to me seems pretty easy maybe i should start doing it to since i was scammed out of all my money. So Now we are breeding Scammers lol. I

Just to be clear I DO AGREE WITH GETTING A PM BEFORE TRADE but as someone stated before the stickys and bull shit yall put the rules in never gets seen or read by most people. So i think they should have to see this rule when they are joining the site.
 
Heidy
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
With hackings going on, nobody should assume anything.

That is what you pulled out of the entire argument. -.-

It's a hypothetical. People that communicate with people constantly aren't going to PM them if there is no obvious reason they should or if they're someone they trade with all of the time. Unless, again, something obvious is wrong.

This ruling is ridiculous, as previously stated.
 
That is what you pulled out of the entire argument. -.-

It's a hypothetical. People that communicate with people constantly aren't going to PM them if there is no obvious reason they should or if they're someone they trade with all of the time. Unless, again, something obvious is wrong.

This ruling is ridiculous, as previously stated.

This will be my last post in this thread on this topic but to be clear on point from my stand point i can totaly agree with you mate. Like a stated before in my post they dont think about the little man just about the people that have been around and know how sythe works.
 
Supporting Business
Discord Voice
Poképedia
Who did this to my freakin' car!
Dat Boi
Dolan Duck
Dolan Trump
I'm LAAAAAAAME
Live Free or Die
Mew
Mewtwo
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Poké Prizebox
Rust Player
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Tier 3 Prizebox
Toast Wallet User
I've been asked to comment on this.

I read through the thread and initially was of the opinion it should be a split liability (as some of you have proposed) but I have since reconsidered.

I do think the current rule should stand (at least until we can try it out properly) and here's why: moral hazard.

One of the reasons our society is in such bad shape today (and getting worse all the time) is that people are being shielded from the consequences of their bad actions. This creates zero incentive for people to research good actions which would lead to good outcomes.

Some of you have proposed that this rule (no pm = no compensation) will lead to a flood of scammings. We should test that hypothesis -- after all there is already a flood of scammings; this is precisely the state of affairs we currently find ourselves in.

I do not however think that this simple penalty will be enough to make people sit up and realise what a risk they are running by not asking for a PM. Large traders should be insisting on PMs, and helping educate the rest of the community on the importance of PMs. Large traders are one of the most hurt groups by scammers. Every dollar stolen from a regular user is a dollar of custom that a large trader failed to receive. If you are a large trader you have every incentive in the world to help educate the userbase.

We want to be proactive about fighting scammers, not reactive. Have some pride in your work and help your customers stay safe in the market place. A mall operator doesn't let punks with flick-knives afflict its patrons, so why should you let e-thugs with social engineering skills afflict yours? Show your customers some care and help them stay safe in the marketplace.
 
I don't see why people are not responsible for their own Skype/MSN/Email/etc Accounts while they are still responsible for their own IP.

If someone is hacked, they should still be responsible for what was scammed - which they may be... but scam reports should not be ignored/locked just because someone's Skype Account was hacked. They should be added to a list of users needing repayment, as when a Staff member posts, "oh.. their Skype is hacked.. sorry.. [exaggerating]", it doesn't mean the user involved should be exempt (as Staff is confirming the Skype Account relation/ownership to the user being reported).
So if i get hacked without wanting it (Yes you could blame the guy who got hacked but you could also blame the Buyer/for example\ for not asking for a pm )
Fact is,if someones skype is hacked and they say to the sythe staff that their skype is hacked and yet people get scammed bcz they do not ask for a pm it's not their fault.
And the last thing they should do is repay them because it's not their fault a hack can happen to everyone.
If someone gets hacked and the hacker scams people with the skype the guy who's got hacked should be not required to pay back OR they can offer it if they want so,but not as a rule.
Really dissapointed in this 1

On topic : Think whatever you want of me,i'm sharing my opinion.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Regardless of whether the rule stays, it might be a good idea to make a global announcement along the lines of "assume all Skypes may be hacked and always get a PM", rather than just announcing users who are hacked. People are more likely to see that than the post in the news / RaS forums.
 
Poképedia
Tier 1 Prizebox
Live Streamer
Pokémon Trainer
The Dark Side
Oktoberfest 2013
MushyMuncher
Rupee
St. Patrick's Day 2013
Poker Chip
Not sure if srs or just newfag...
Ninja
Tortoise Penis
DIAF
St. Patrick's Day 2014
Cool Kid
Cook
Heidy
Halloween 2013
Village Drunk
Voluntaryist
We Are Legion
Penguin
I find nearly this whole statement outrageous.

How in the name of god is someone getting rewarded by getting what they are owed?

I am shocked that such a statement came from someone of authority on this site.

That was by no means an authoritative statement, nor an end all decision. That is merely my opinion as an ex-market user and a person, and I'm entitled to such. I'm still open to arguments and suggestions, just making MY OPINION known, just as the rest of you are.
 
<3 n4n0
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Community Participant
Spam Forum Participant
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2011 Winner
In my opinion, we should. They were stupid enough to not get verification before a trade when we preach every day, "GET A PM!"

We have multitudes of guides out there. Stickies with massive amounts of information in regards to safe trading practices. And plenty of experienced users that can give insight to the new users IF THEY TOOK THE TIME TO EVEN ASK.

It's not our fault, nor the victim of the hacked skype that these people are too goddamn lazy and incompetent to follow safe trading practices, and we shouldn't reward their stupidity.

New users are extremely easy to SE. If who they think is a large trusted market member tells them they don't need a PM and give a few bull shit excuses they will very likely listen.

I've been asked to comment on this.

I read through the thread and initially was of the opinion it should be a split liability (as some of you have proposed) but I have since reconsidered.

I do think the current rule should stand (at least until we can try it out properly) and here's why: moral hazard.

One of the reasons our society is in such bad shape today (and getting worse all the time) is that people are being shielded from the consequences of their bad actions. This creates zero incentive for people to research good actions which would lead to good outcomes.

Some of you have proposed that this rule (no pm = no compensation) will lead to a flood of scammings. We should test that hypothesis -- after all there is already a flood of scammings; this is precisely the state of affairs we currently find ourselves in.

I do not however think that this simple penalty will be enough to make people sit up and realise what a risk they are running by not asking for a PM. Large traders should be insisting on PMs, and helping educate the rest of the community on the importance of PMs. Large traders are one of the most hurt groups by scammers. Every dollar stolen from a regular user is a dollar of custom that a large trader failed to receive. If you are a large trader you have every incentive in the world to help educate the userbase.

We want to be proactive about fighting scammers, not reactive. Have some pride in your work and help your customers stay safe in the market place. A mall operator doesn't let punks with flick-knives afflict its patrons, so why should you let e-thugs with social engineering skills afflict yours? Show your customers some care and help them stay safe in the marketplace.

The issue of scamming isn't really any large number of new scams, its trusted members being able to scam large amounts and get away with it if the person doesn't insist on a PM. All they have to do is fake being hacked and then they get away scot free without us being able to tell (generally).
 
UWotM8?
<3 n4n0
Oktoberfest 2013
Village Drunk
Shitting Rainbow
Potamus
Sythe Awards 2012 Winner
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
MushyMuncher
I've been asked to comment on this.

I read through the thread and initially was of the opinion it should be a split liability (as some of you have proposed) but I have since reconsidered.

I do think the current rule should stand (at least until we can try it out properly) and here's why: moral hazard.

One of the reasons our society is in such bad shape today (and getting worse all the time) is that people are being shielded from the consequences of their bad actions. This creates zero incentive for people to research good actions which would lead to good outcomes.

Some of you have proposed that this rule (no pm = no compensation) will lead to a flood of scammings. We should test that hypothesis -- after all there is already a flood of scammings; this is precisely the state of affairs we currently find ourselves in.

I do not however think that this simple penalty will be enough to make people sit up and realise what a risk they are running by not asking for a PM. Large traders should be insisting on PMs, and helping educate the rest of the community on the importance of PMs. Large traders are one of the most hurt groups by scammers. Every dollar stolen from a regular user is a dollar of custom that a large trader failed to receive. If you are a large trader you have every incentive in the world to help educate the userbase.

We want to be proactive about fighting scammers, not reactive. Have some pride in your work and help your customers stay safe in the market place. A mall operator doesn't let punks with flick-knives afflict its patrons, so why should you let e-thugs with social engineering skills afflict yours? Show your customers some care and help them stay safe in the marketplace.

A 50-50 liability would do exactly the same thing, except it would be much more fair. People would still be just as hesitant to lose half of whatever they're selling.

I know where you're coming from; it would be best to educate the community than to shield them from the hazards, whereas these scams would continue to happen. However, it seems to me that a 50-50 liability (which is more FAIR), would both help educate the new users as well as serve some form of fairness so that they are not out all their money when somebody gets hacked.

I just personally don't think its fair that a user doesn't get any compensation when he gets scammed by SOMEBODY ELSES hacker. If you ask me they are both responsible (the victim of the hacking and the victim of the scamming).

Just please think it over with respect to the fact that a 50-50 liability would serve both purposes, fairness and education.
 
Heidy
Sythe's 10th Anniversary
I see this as changing the rules in the middle of the game. Now you don't have to be responsible for getting hacked and losing control of your account, when for all the time I have been here you were always responsible for both your accounts and IP. What systems are in place to prevent people from buying a $30 VPN, running through a proxy, and faking a hacking? You could profit way more than you spend in the long run by doing this. This is opening up a pandora's box of variables that haven't been account for as of now.

Taking pride costs too much time for the large sellers to give a damn about their customers. When was the last time you saw R2P in the forum actively trying to help new members learn to trade? Or Busta? Or Tjin? I have to give it up for Grave though because sometimes he is a troll, but I do feel he can, at times, have what is good for the community as a whole and not just his bottom line in mind. This wait and see attitude isn't a proactive one...
 
I don't even think a partial compensation is deserved, assuming everyone isn't completely oblivious to the rule. Members just have to get a PM every single transaction, it really isn't that hard. This rule protects both parties. Personally I am not confident with any IM service. Initially I thought hotmail was secure but nope, got exploited. So I moved to Skype, nope still exploits. So yeah this is good to help protect sellers to a certain point.

I guess the real problem is members being ignorant towards the rule so as Sythe said everyone should help promote this rule. I will start advertising in my signature to only trade me with PM confirmation.
 
Two Factor Authentication User
Few things should be cleared up by the Admins or whoever decides this:

  • Duration of compensation period? I.E, after an announcement is made making individuals aware of such and suchs Skype being hacked.
  • Prior to announcement being made, is Skype holder liable?
  • What if staff are unavailable to make an announcement after Skype holder has sent a PM stating their Skype being hacked; is the Skype holder still liable?

Can we can an insight into this?
 
UWotM8?
<3 n4n0
Oktoberfest 2013
Village Drunk
Shitting Rainbow
Potamus
Sythe Awards 2012 Winner
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
MushyMuncher
Bump.

I really don't agree with and never will agree with there being a 0% reimbursement to victims of scams by hackers.

Keep in mind, the ones who own the hacked Skype are the ones who choose to use that for their services during a hacking spree. They could have easily switched IM services either permanently or temporarily. Their customers will follow them to whatever IM service they use, as they have no choice, so in light of this I place even more blame on the sellers.
 
Back
Top