[Denied]Appeal transparency

Currently we have a list of decisions
Pardon Decisions [2025]

I'd say giving users more insight in to why certain appeals arend accepted and keep getting denied would provide more incentive for users to repay and be allowed to join the markets again

 

Hard to do this due to sensitive information and not all cases being created equal. Sometimes the decision to approve or reject an appeal goes beyond the pardon itself, which requires discussion amongst the staff. If certain trends are identified, it could entice people to scam and then otherwise just pardon and come back repeatedly.

 

Hard to do this due to sensitive information and not all cases being created equal. Sometimes the decision to approve or reject an appeal goes beyond the pardon itself, which requires discussion amongst the staff. If certain trends are identified, it could entice people to scam and then otherwise just pardon and come back repeatedly.

This - no support.

Users are free to reach out to staff & staff can advise on their decisions if they feel the need

 

[OsrsSkillz]

I agree Transparency would be better regarding the sensitive information Could be blocked out and update the thread at the bottom for the reasons and who supported and who didn't for what reasons.

 

[Utopia]

Looks like staff votes on pardons. If the pardon is denied, you can assume it is because they got more no than yes votes. Staff discretion shouldn't be public.

 

I think if relevancy pertains to the affected party at their request it’s fine. In the eyes of the public it’s not warranted nor necessary imo

 

Users who request a pardon are able to reach out to individual staff members for feedback after a denial. What @Hahanerd said above is also relevant:

Hard to do this due to sensitive information and not all cases being created equal. Sometimes the decision to approve or reject an appeal goes beyond the pardon itself, which requires discussion amongst the staff. If certain trends are identified, it could entice people to scam and then otherwise just pardon and come back repeatedly.