• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

[DENIED] Allow donating to the staff

Status
Not open for further replies.
Its a gesture of kindness more than anything. Staff shouldn't be expecting much from it, and it will probably be towards the very low $x amount a month, perhaps $xx if you're lucky.

Let's make a scenario; our friend @Pendulum has no job and he's a volunteer mod here. He rarely deals in the market place, and he's quite happy with it. Snce sythe is a diverse forum, one day a person notices Pendi working hard (banning noobs and denying pardons, you know the normal stuff) He decides to tip pendi $10 which is a very generous amount. Pendi sees the donation coming in, he feels a bit happy and thinks about what to do with the money, so he decides to buy a bond or maybe orders from Micky D's. Pendi is happy, doesn't feel burnt out and keeps doing what he does.

While sythe has had some notably corrupt staff in the distant past (who have been dismissed for corruption) namely Finn, Pen, and a few others, we endeavour to keep the staff as honest as possible. It is quite difficult to get away with corruption these days as there are so many eyes on everyone. Staff cross check each other's decisions and behaviour more rigorously than (probably) ever before and provide performance reviews on eachother at the end of each month.
 
Nitro Booster
Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Easter 2019
Lawrence
Summer 2020
Christmas 2021
Christmas 2022
CoolHam
Easter 2021
Easter 2022
Halloween 2021
St. Patrick's Day 2019
St. Patrick's Day 2022
Summer 2023
Tier 1 Prizebox
Valentine's Day 2022
Winter Olympics 2022
Nah this would just cultivate bad staff practise e.g. everyone liked Wortel but he got demoted for a reason. Besides, staff can already utilise their status to boost their sythe income in other ways. Plenty of people would do it for free, for non-wage factors.

No support
 
Last edited:
Shuppet
Starmie
Pidgeotto
Wurmple
Member of the Month Winner
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
Pokémon Trainer
March Madness
Poképedia
Discord Verified
Nitro Booster
Easter 2023
The Glizz
Two Factor Authentication User
Easter 2025
Valentine's Day 2025
Halloween 2024
St. Patrick's Day 2025
Christmas 2024
Heidy
Staff of the Quarter Winner
Lawrence
Tons of Damage
Summer 2025
Easter 2022
Verified Ironman
To be fair, although I agree with a lot of opionions about the possible corruption, I don't think a donating option would make this easier. You could already message a mod and try to bribe them if you would like. By adding a donation option ( which could also be an anonymous donation ) mods could even see who gets a lot of donations.

I don't think it's worth the development time, but I don't think it would make it easier to bribe someone.
So no support.
 
Homosex
NO SUPPORT ROFL.

People will apply for money and they will be doing the work they do for the wrong reasons, staff would see dollar bills and they won’t be able to remain unbiased even if they wanted to.
 
Lets not underestimate the abilities of our staff, the current staff are given much less credit than they deserve.
 
Nitro Booster
Homosex
Two Factor Authentication User
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Easter 2019
Lawrence
Summer 2020
Christmas 2021
Christmas 2022
CoolHam
Easter 2021
Easter 2022
Halloween 2021
St. Patrick's Day 2019
St. Patrick's Day 2022
Summer 2023
Tier 1 Prizebox
Valentine's Day 2022
Winter Olympics 2022
Lets not underestimate the abilities of our staff, the current staff are given much less credit than they deserve.
Yes, lets not underestimate them by suggesting they need our donations. It'll create more problems than what it may solve.

Monetising a staff rank is easy enough.
 
Dragon Claws
Halloween 2023
I like the idea, but in reality this can just be done behind the scenes. Contact mod of choice: "Hey man, I really appreciate the work that you've been doing. Drop your BTC addy and i'll leave a tip!"

But if this were to pass, it most definitely would need to be anonymous for obvious reasons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PAK
Two Factor Authentication User
Absolutely not. Most of my reasoning has already been posted by other users, so won't regurgitate the same thing.
 
Why not add the donate button and allow users to donate Sythe Gold to mods. This can then be sold. It would also provide a slightly bigger market for Sythe gold, for said do-gooders to buy and donate.
 
Why not add the donate button and allow users to donate Sythe Gold to mods. This can then be sold. It would also provide a slightly bigger market for Sythe gold, for said do-gooders to buy and donate.

A) Sythe gold is quite useless
B) No different from a normal donation button
C) Even if there were a market for sythe gold, this clearly doesnt resolve the slippery slope issues all of us have pointed out, and creates a competitive popularity culture.

Being a good mod isnt about being popular. Its about being fair, and being willing to dole out punishment even to popular users who have the ability to drag you thru the mud, even your own friends. You turn on donations, you turn this whole moderating culture into who's-the-most-popular-moderator? What then?
 
A) Sythe gold is quite useless
B) No different from a normal donation button
C) Even if there were a market for sythe gold, this clearly doesnt resolve the slippery slope issues all of us have pointed out, and creates a competitive popularity culture.

Being a good mod isnt about being popular. Its about being fair, and being willing to dole out punishment even to popular users who have the ability to drag you thru the mud, even your own friends. You turn on donations, you turn this whole moderating culture into who's-the-most-popular-moderator? What then?

You're right. What about a Sythe Moderator "Tip" button. This is evenly shared out between all mods and grateful users of sythe can donate to a bond-holder or a staff member to have it added to the pot. This could be shared out monthly or quarterly.
 
Air Fryer
DIAF
m`lady
Le Kingdoms Player
STEVE
Creamy
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Pool Shark
Two Factor Authentication User
the fact that every current/ex-staff member who has posted here thinks this is a bad idea should be enough to deny it. on top of the issues mentioned, you then have the problem of apportioning the (presumably anonymous) donations once they're collected. should all staff get the same share? when do you distribute payments? what about staff that were active for a part of a week/month/year?

i think we'd all be happier if you took the money you want to send to staff and donated it to a charity instead
 
Christmas 2024
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Member of the Month Winner
OG Club
Christmas 2013
Wait, do you not have an Archer rank?
Winter Olympics 2022
March Madness
Easter 2020
Christmas 2021
Valentine's Day 2022
Easter 2022
Summer 2022
Halloween 2022
Christmas 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2022
St. Patrick's Day 2023
Valentine's Day 2023
Summer 2023
Easter 2023
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe's 20th Anniversary
Poképedia
Christmas 2023
Halloween 2023
HamSanta
Easter 2024
PHP Shit Show 2k26
You're right. What about a Sythe Moderator "Tip" button. This is evenly shared out between all mods and grateful users of sythe can donate to a bond-holder or a staff member to have it added to the pot. This could be shared out monthly or quarterly.

Read through previous posts. This can still easily lead to a situation where people aim for staff positions for all of the wrong reasons man.
 
Sythe's 15th Anniversary
Sythe Awards 2016 Winner
Sythe Awards 2017 Winner
Sythe Awards 2018 Winner
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Sythe Awards 2020 Winner
Sythe Awards 2021 Winner
Sythe Awards 2022 Winner
Sythe Awards 2023 Winner
Sythe Awards 2024 Winner
I saw Matthew
OG Club
Discord Verified
SytheSteamer
WoW Classic
Member of the Month Winner
Photography Competition Winner
In Memory of Jon
May the 4th Be With You
Member of the Quarter Winner
Two Factor Authentication User
Detective
Carrot
PHP Shit Show 2k26
Sythe Awards 2025 Winner
This is already happening, how else do you think @video survives this long? All jokes aside ofcourse, no support per obvious reasons. The fuck is up with those suggestions lol.
 
Toast Wallet User
Discord Verified
Two Factor Authentication User
Verified Ironman
Sythe Awards 2019 Winner
Nitro Booster
Poképedia
This is already happening, how else do you think @video survives this long? All jokes aside ofcourse, no support per obvious reasons. The fuck is up with those suggestions lol.

This would have helped you out in the past though wink wink

I joke <3
 
Listen, Sythe is a great forum I come to speak about truth. What harm is there to set a permanent public btc address and not allowing staff to ask for donations. It's all transparent anyway, and in cases where people think staff will abuse this, just start questioning if someone is getting more than $10 a month. It'll be obvious.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
duelarena.gg
Back
Top