2/10 for both, my 9 year old brother could do the same =], if these are your first ever sigs then they are ok for a beginner. By the way u judged me I'm guessing your not one.
Meanwhile, getting back on subject... I don't really like them that much, to much empty space in there. It looks like you just blurred the hell out of the dog one, but the elf one looks a little bit better.
Quit the fucking drama. The sig isn't that bad if you just got into gfx. Hell, I couldn't make a sig at all when I got into gfx. Good compared to what I used to do. Try to use some more advanced tutorials. They help a lot.
I really lol'd. I didnt spam your thread, your sigs do get a 2/10 they are bad, all you did was use some filters woooooo. heres a psd of the sig im using atm. I added white on the left of each layer so no one can use them. http://www.megaupload.com/?d=M23TD75B