What's the proof of him recovering it? You only have proof of trading with him..
I have paid Cyclops before him actually doing anything for me, and he have gone on my Maxed pure (1 def), with over 30m total value. 99 ranged, fire cape, etc. And haven't touched a thing! He is a really nice guy and I sincerely hope he will be unbanned soon.
He's on it atm actually -.-