I really like the second one, but the first one has some issues. First the focal being colorized jut throws the piece off and I am not a fan of the mixture of the lighting stock and the smoke/ink stock in the background. I kind of get the floating head thing from it as I think she is blended too well with the background, textures, and effects. I can also see where imagine is getting the no clear flow but I have to disagree; there is flow but it needs some work. I also find it lacking lighting and depth.