• Log in or sign up for an account here: https://www.sythe.org/login

Communism or Anarchy?

jd 365

jd 365

Guru

$5 USD Donor
Joined
Feb 20, 2007
Sythe Gold
0
Messages
1,201
Do you beleive the world (if it was a perfect would) would be better off with communism or anarchy?

For those of you who do not know what communism and anarchy is

Communism: Every one is rich and poor, every one has equal amount of power and every one shares the same beleifes (which is why most communists atheists)
Anarchy: "A theoretical social state in which there is no governing person or body of persons, but each individual has absolute liberty (without the implication of disorder)


Now lets say there is no human nature who is craving power and this is a perfect world, these are both almost exactully the same but communists have a leader that makes all the decisions.

Which one would bear better fruit for the world.
 
I rather go with Anarchy because I think communism you like slaves you could never get rich your average but if you anarchy you can be rich no goverment break rules too
 
Not sure if srs or just newfag...
Ottis said:
I rather go with Anarchy because I think communism you like slaves you could never get rich your average but if you anarchy you can be rich no goverment break rules too
Click to expand...

But the world is perfect.
 
Communism is a religion - it holds the good of all as its highest value.

I'd rather not subscribe to any agenda but my own.
 
With Communism, societies can still function. With Anarchy, there is no society. We'd be going back to a world of apes and we'd be fighting for scrapes of food.
 
Communism is almost perfect in theory, but it simply doesn't work in real life.

I think anarchy would work. Most of the violence associated with anarchy is propaganda. Abolition of control not whiskered men with bombs.
 
Anarchy definetly. No rules as is communism is slavery type treating you like shit and government upholds the power you have little.
 
Omniscient said:
With Communism, societies can still function. With Anarchy, there is no society. We'd be going back to a world of apes and we'd be fighting for scrapes of food.
Click to expand...

Political anarchy just means the removal of government. It does not mean chaos.
 
Neither would work im sorry to say but as a punk rocker id say anarchy but i am sure that wouldnt last ppl would gang together and start almost tribes that would eventially have a leader... so it wouldnt last and communism can function as some have said its not all horrible god wtf are you guys 8 years old read about communism... look at russia before stalin it was gonna be perfect! Until Stalin started using communism against the society.... it was supposed to be a utopia and it turned into a distopia im freaking 14 years old and figured this out god ppl are dumb lol.... I may have made grammar mistakes cuz im just typing like crazy but I still got my point across I hope?
 
Communism, just because Anarchy is horrible. I wouldn't want to live in an area where we have no leader. People would go crazy and chaotic.
 
DrumBum said:
Communism, just because Anarchy is horrible. I wouldn't want to live in an area where we have no leader. People would go crazy and chaotic.
Click to expand...

bizcuits21 said:
Despite the fact that I hate both, communism because a goverment, even dictatorial communism, is better than no government.
Click to expand...

A communist society does not have a government.
 
l33er th4n l33t said:
Neither would work im sorry to say but as a punk rocker id say anarchy but i am sure that wouldnt last ppl would gang together and start almost tribes that would eventially have a leader... so it wouldnt last and communism can function as some have said its not all horrible god wtf are you guys 8 years old read about communism... look at russia before stalin it was gonna be perfect! Until Stalin started using communism against the society.... it was supposed to be a utopia and it turned into a distopia im freaking 14 years old and figured this out god ppl are dumb lol.... I may have made grammar mistakes cuz im just typing like crazy but I still got my point across I hope?
Click to expand...

are you 3 years old? This is a post dictating if we had a "Perfect world" which of either communism or anarchy would you choose, there is a simple answer all you had to do was answer it and say why, most of us should know what happend to russia, but in a perfect world that would not have happened.
 
There is no perfect world
 
Anarchy, because in communism you say something bad against the dictator then he kills you, it's stupid and dictators are just too much, if communism did not have a dictator then sure I'll go with communism.
 
Anarchy without a doubt.
Communism is slavery, you cannot get rich and cannot get poor. It's...wrong!
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by l33er th4n l33t View Post
Neither would work im sorry to say but as a punk rocker id say anarchy but i am sure that wouldnt last ppl would gang together and start almost tribes that would eventially have a leader... so it wouldnt last and communism can function as some have said its not all horrible god wtf are you guys 8 years old read about communism... look at russia before stalin it was gonna be perfect! Until Stalin started using communism against the society.... it was supposed to be a utopia and it turned into a distopia im freaking 14 years old and figured this out god ppl are dumb lol.... I may have made grammar mistakes cuz im just typing like crazy but I still got my point across I hope?
Click to expand...
are you 3 years old? This is a post dictating if we had a "Perfect world" which of either communism or anarchy would you choose, there is a simple answer all you had to do was answer it and say why, most of us should know what happend to russia, but in a perfect world that would not have happened.
Click to expand...
He quite clearly said he was 14. A 14 year old that thinks he knows what there is to know but doesn't. Punk rocker? You were not even alive during the haydays of punk rock, you're a trend whore.

Anyways, back on topic.

If this world really was 'perfect', then the obvious choice would be communism. The communist theory, is in fact, a very good idea. Equality. Which, in a perfect world, would work. In practice however, an anarchy system has been proven to work better than the communist system; which has caused all sorts of world problems over the years. If I could add my own third choice, it would be capitalism. Look at America, despite having several problems, they are still THE major world power.

Perfect world:

1. Communism
2. Anarchy
= Capitalism

In practice:

1. Capitalism
2. Anarchy
-BIG GAP-
3. Communism.
 
Anarchy.
Simply because you decide for yourself. You don't work for the better of the whole, you work for the better of yourself and whoever you want to work for, like your family or something I guess. I think Anarchy is much better than communism.

The Communists are distinguished from the other working-class parties by this only: 1. In the national struggles of the proletarians of the different countries, they point out and bring to the front the common interests of the entire proletariat, independently of all nationality. 2. In the various stages of development which the struggle of the working class against the bourgeoisie has to pass through, they always and everywhere represent the interests of the movement as a whole.
Click to expand...
Communist manifesto.

Now to me this sounds like it's good. But if this was true, and if the people would always think of the "whole" there will always be someone who will feel left out, or maybe feel lazy and such. So they will not think of the whole, and that will cause the problems in Commnunism. Your perfect world said (I think) that no one has the urge to be more powerful, no one is greedy but you forget the pitfalls of mankind itself, laziness. Someone will be frustrated from doing work and will start slacking off, and then the "whole" cannot be complete. Right? Sorry if I'm wrong :(

In my very limited knowledge, that was my opinion...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Runescape Gamblingrunescape gambling
Back
Top