As i always say in every CTC i do, I have no room to talk. But the first one the text is a little choppy and sloppy looking and doesnt really "Pop" Maybe if you made the text in like a white outline or glow or something it would pop and make it look great. As far as the animation goes its good but i just think the fire is a bit too much. Kinda seemed like you ran out of things to add to it, But if the fire is what you like then i disregard what i said. For both signatures id give you about a 6, Nothing too special (Better than me) but it still just doesnt grab my attetion. Please keep up the good work though, I really enjoy seeing everyones work and i like to learn from it. Btw use the one you are now.