Well, I was just trying Al-Karid Warriors, and it didn't eat for me.
Monsterfighter has tons of flaws.
Doesn't pick up the items corrosponding to the IDs, picks up bones/arrows when it is turned off, and walks off in the middle of a fight, getting lost.
Edit: I think I'll just keep it on Fightcaves. I had that on for a good hour last night without any problems, probably seems like the best choice.