Not really, soul split is a lot better than smite, and when using dragon claws/dds the turmoil zerker will hit higher.
"The 60 attack build does not have the accuracy in the D scim even with Turmoil to effectively combat the 80 attack builds huge boost in accuracy."
"The 80 attack build has a significantly higher max hit than the 60 attack one, that coupled with the accuracy and the frequency those rapier hits are going to come at will prove significantly better than the 60 attack with Turmoil."
....
"60 99 45 with Turmoil and 99 HP = 99 combat.
The max hit with Dragon Scimitar is roughly 420.
80 99 45 with 45 Prayer and 99 HP = 99 combat.
The max hit with Chaotic Rapier is roughly 460
The max hit with Chaotic Longsword is roughly 500 (cls is just a tick slower than dscim)
The max hit with Korasi's Sword is rougly 390 (same speed as dscim with a useful special that hits about 600)
Not only does the second build have more weapons available to it - it's more accurate, and hits higher with chaotic. Soul split is countered with protection prayers, pro melee if someone soul splits you and leechs aren't something to concern yourself with, because they can't be activated when turmoil is on. "
....
"i don't think everyone pk's like scim -> scim -> spec -> spec. If not dead, TELE@@@
The point people are trying to make is that, with 80 attack, a chaotic can get you kills if your dds didn't kill."
________________
All quotes from a discussion we had on different forums.