[Resolved]

Link the current Sythe account: Dalbert
Which violation you are reporting the user for: Plagiarism
Why you think they're violating Sythe rules:

As of 2023-03-12, these were the bots I had:

Here's a GIF of which bot he has and which date he added them:

All of the similar bots that I have has been "rooted". No other bot than those I had added has been added 12th of March, 2023.

This is BoostedMMO's how-to-shop guide.

This is his copy but re-worded without the GIF:

It has been copied and re-worded. It's the exact same format as we use, precisely in order. But in different words than our.

So I thought I'd give him a warning because I saw multiple embeds being very very similar to mine.
Even tho he has me blocked, I joined his server and kindly asked him to private message me where I re-sent the message and this was his response:

I understand it has been developed as it's a custom bot. But there was not a hard investigation and let me prove how:

I would first off like to start with an assumption. This bot may not even work because they don't have an official channel to calculate quests or skills.

However, if I'm correct, why would you have abbreviation advertised if there's no bot to calculate with?
Here's a picture of BoostedMMO's:

Calculating with abbreviations actually work on our discord with an official channel for self-calculating with a custom bot.
Here's Loyalty Services:

Why is it listed 1-10 exactly like ours? Just re-worded differently with no use of a bot to calculate.

Here is the fun part of your "hard investigation":
Here's BoostedMMO Skills Prices:

Look at the list in which order it goes. And keep it mind that Magic doesn't advertise Sand Crabs like Ranged and Melee does.
Here's Loyalty Services:

Remember how I said Magic didn't have Sand Crabs advertised?
As of matter of a fact, we actually do advertise Sand Crabs for Magic. I just seem to have forgotten that method, but it wouldn't really matter as we calculate appropriately via the bot regardless.

Now as continue down the list of your "skilling":
Here's BoostedMMO's second part of Skilling:

If you take a real good look at Herblore, Fletching, Slayer... Actually all but Mining.
Here's Loyalty Services:

Comparison between both:

Where is the hard investigation he mentioned? Herblore is straight up copy paste. Slayer is straight up Copy paste. Hunter is copy paste just re-listed and re-worded differently.

Now let's be honest, who even trains Fletching with Rune Darts? I have it there just as an option but most people usually choose Adamant Darts. However for Loyalty Services, I don't know if it's 67-99 Fletching via Adamant Darts or just a writing error and forgot to copy paste Adamant Darts.

Now I know people make mistakes, so I thought I'd give him the benefit to at least have a chance to learn from his mistake.
Upon bringing it up to him, this was a quick change he made:

He changed the name from "Gathering" to "iron-needs"

I'd like to end this with this:
This is Loyalty Service's Emoji on Create a ticket:

And this is BoostedMMO's:

Sincerely,
Chaddy.

 

[President]

Hi @Dalbert

What do you have to say to this?

 

Hey @President, how is it going

this is the osrs skills tab, it has the skills in the exact same order as it's published on the order, att, str, def, ranged,, i've seen many discords do that "format" and it seems fine for me, as it's the order that the skilsl appear on the game.

https://i.imgur.com/ZguvEv1.png - as the img above wont post, this is the direct link

https://i.imgur.com/tbvYZ09.png

as the img above doesn't appear, this is the direct link.

The "rfd1" bkm, bim, or those short-commands, are the first letters of every word of a quest's name, which are used in our own custom bot that is being developed by us.

regards the bots, those are bots that are free to use on discord, i can use whichever i need because discord permits it, here for example, is the one that Mr.C claims to be not working and i quote: "I would first off like to start with an assumption. This bot may not even work because they don't have an official channel to calculate quests or skills."

On the picture above, you can see the bot does work but it's under development, a custom bot, not like something you can purchase somewhere on a shop, i've seen their calculator and it's almost the same format as other discords, as many of them purchase a same format for example, from sythe shop, and at the end, what would that even matter, what's the point

As he starts off assumption and thinks his discord is the only one in the world.

The skilling methods for the majority of abilities are pretty much the same ones, and are capped at certain levels as the exp gained by every skill is different, that's why the xp/gp changes as you lvl up, for example for hunter, 47-59 orange salamander, then you jump into red salamander at 59-67, it's a rule, it's a must.

i remember them having a gathering section, and as he told me to change things on my discord via PM, i changed to iron-needs, i was hiding so much and copied so much, that i just changed a sections name? doesn't seem logic at all.

I can tell that i was certainly inspired by bmmo since limiq founded it before, and as well as many others, i worked with boostedmmo for over 4 years and some things were pretty mechanic, for example the gathering name on the gathering section, you literally gather/collect stuff, but just that, inspiration, from the original vision they had.

In any case if any of my actions doesn't go along with the appropiate way of labeling a discord as stated by sythe, taking in consideration that the game itself has pretty limited activities and straight forward ones, let me know and we'll sort the inconvenient out the best possible way.

@President

Regards the ticket icon btw, i liked that one.

it's very important to mention that i was kicked from the bmmo's discord since the previous incident then i made my own after that, so there's no actual way for me to check his discord, which that discord as well recently got deleted because they inflicting discord T.O.S, so they made a new one like a month ago.

 

it's very important to mention that i was kicked from the bmmo's discord since the previous incident then i made my own after that, so there's no actual way for me to check his discord, which that discord as well recently got deleted because they inflicting discord T.O.S, so they made a new one like a month ago.

Irrelevant at best. I’ve had an eye on your discord for two months. I’ve had 8 different alternative accounts on your discord. Yesterday was my first time joining your discord with my main account. I have pictures from your discord 2 months back.

 

Hey @President, how is it going

this is the osrs skills tab, it has the skills in the exact same order as it's published on the order, att, str, def, ranged,, i've seen many discords do that "format" and it seems fine for me, as it's the order that the skilsl appear on the game.

https://i.imgur.com/ZguvEv1.png - as the img above wont post, this is the direct link

https://i.imgur.com/tbvYZ09.png

as the img above doesn't appear, this is the direct link.

The "rfd1" bkm, bim, or those short-commands, are the first letters of every word of a quest's name, which are used in our own custom bot that is being developed by us.

regards the bots, those are bots that are free to use on discord, i can use whichever i need because discord permits it, here for example, is the one that Mr.C claims to be not working and i quote: "I would first off like to start with an assumption. This bot may not even work because they don't have an official channel to calculate quests or skills."

On the picture above, you can see the bot does work but it's under development, a custom bot, not like something you can purchase somewhere on a shop, i've seen their calculator and it's almost the same format as other discords, as many of them purchase a same format for example, from sythe shop, and at the end, what would that even matter, what's the point

As he starts off assumption and thinks his discord is the only one in the world.

The skilling methods for the majority of abilities are pretty much the same ones, and are capped at certain levels as the exp gained by every skill is different, that's why the xp/gp changes as you lvl up, for example for hunter, 47-59 orange salamander, then you jump into red salamander at 59-67, it's a rule, it's a must.

i remember them having a gathering section, and as he told me to change things on my discord via PM, i changed to iron-needs, i was hiding so much and copied so much, that i just changed a sections name? doesn't seem logic at all.

I can tell that i was certainly inspired by bmmo since limiq founded it before, and as well as many others, i worked with boostedmmo for over 4 years and some things were pretty mechanic, for example the gathering name on the gathering section, you literally gather/collect stuff, but just that, inspiration, from the original vision they had.

In any case if any of my actions doesn't go along with the appropiate way of labeling a discord as stated by sythe, taking in consideration that the game itself has pretty limited activities and straight forward ones, let me know and we'll sort the inconvenient out the best possible way.

@President

Regards the ticket icon btw, i liked that one.

it's very important to mention that i was kicked from the bmmo's discord since the previous incident then i made my own after that, so there's no actual way for me to check his discord, which that discord as well recently got deleted because they inflicting discord T.O.S, so they made a new one like a month ago.

Can you prove your wordings? The only things you've shown is practically shown doesn't show that you in fact did plagiarize. Your methods are very very copied if you compare it to mine. Herblore? Slayer? Low Level? High Level? Can you even prove another discord that has that exact methods and those wording since you mention:

this is the osrs skills tab, it has the skills in the exact same order as it's published on the order, att, str, def, ranged,, i've seen many discords do that "format" and it seems fine for me, as it's the order that the skilsl appear on the game.

How come all other discords offers Sand Crabs on Magic, but you in particular and specifically you, do not?

 

[President]

Dear gentlemen, thank you for your patience.

While there are elements that appear to draw inspiration from BoostedMMO's embeds (which can be explained by Dalbert's recent employment at BoostedMMO), there is not enough evidence to conclude that plagiarism has occurred.

There is, however, a minor point that borders on plagiarism: the RFD part. BoostedMMO is correct in asserting that the order of the quests is strikingly similar. However, the text and prices differ from those of BoostedMMO. Nonetheless, I kindly request @Dalbert to modify this part, to clearly indicate that it is your creation.

Thank you for reading and have a nice weekend,

Closing