It's not that bad. Actually they're pretty good. Also since you made them in GIMP instead of Photoshop CS3 or something. I give it a 7/10 for good effort!
Too crowded man, that is something real easy you can improve on. You have no need for three of those token's. Clever putting lava up for the Fire Cape n stuff. I would recommend using brushes instead of effects though. Google deviantart gimp brushes to download some, should come with readme's too. Also have a mess around with all the things GIMP can do, get a feel for the program.
yea i only have been useing GIMP for makeing things transparent and i started to play around with other things the lava was a render =] lol i havent got used to layers n' such but im getting used to it