The first I don't like due to the lack of blending and effects. It seems like a beginner sig to me using a few spatter brushes for the background and apply bad text.
The second is just bad c4d usage bad lighting bad effects bad text and that spatter over it is just beyond bad.
Also both's borders are bad, either no border or just 1 px black it. not 2-4 px.
3/10 overall.