This seller's excuse for not wanting to go first was because I was a newcomer, but the truth is both of our accounts were created on the same month and year. All my trades have been code first so I can verify it on battle.net and payment after.
I even showed him my vouches on other forums and he said he doesn't trust other forums so I told him it was fine that we don't trade. I told him there are other sellers.
Vouching for LolReferrals, super patient (I was AFK for 20 minutes when he contacted me!!), polite, simple and easy. Went first with the key, got payment within -seconds-. Recommended.