Am I in the wrong?

[Foxichu]

So, I'm in Fally with my friends, and someone randomly trades me at the bank. I figure "what's up, probably got a drop?". The guy puts up an SGS and a Fury. I think "What?". He accepts, and it goes to the second trade screen. I figure he's just going to decline, and he accepts. Afterwards, I thank him, and walk away. He walks up to me 5 seconds later and says he accidentally traded it to me. I told him it's his own fault, and logged. Am I wrong?

 

[Father 2h]

Hahahaha you did the right thing. Idiots = Idiots. His goal was to make you feel stupid by making you happy to have a chance at getting such items. Now, he looks like a fool. CONGRATS!

 

[malyce]

Well, yes and no. It's a bit dishonest, but he did make the mistake. If it was me I'd have given it back, but I'm pretty old school (back in classic I gave a guy 5k and he gave me rune legs for it, first rune item I ever had. He told me that honor was more important than wealth, and took off).

 

[Themaulpure]

You can't accidentally trade.

He's an idiot.

 

[Tckr]

Nope, those items are now yours.

 

[cadvahn]

he was trying to get your hopes up and then crush them and he failed at that. he doesn't deserve to get his items back.

 

[Delta Squad]

Simple.

Ask yourself this, If you did the same thing, Would HE return the items.

If not, keep em.

 

[oxodium]

Maybe he was rwt? And just didn't check the user, sometimes I get spam traded when I'm trying to trade a gp buyer.

If he just randomly traded you that, then he's either crazy, or loaded.

 

[FacelessVoid]

gj on getting free 20m

 

[Foxichu]

^40m.

He said he was trying to trade his friend and misclicked me.

 

[raflo1]

If you would've made that mistake , would anyone give you the items back ? Maybe 0.01% of the players would do a kind gesture . Now it just depends if you feel sorry for him and the 0.01% percentage includes you too , or not :nuts:

 

[Dungeon Technique]

nope keem them. its his fault

 

[Thug_Life]

Ehh, it was most likely his friend who logged in and did something stupid. Naw, you're not in the wrong, you're lucky.

 

[Niini]

Yes you're in the wrong, it was a honest mistake and the only thing stopping you from giving them back was the way you were raised

So I guess in that sense it wasn't your fault at all

 

[ønePartyhat]

"Oh look, an accept button; lets click it; OH MY GOD, another accept button" *click* "DOH"

 

[TheMaker]

well done, you just learned a noob by his mistake. you did good today!

 

[HypeKid57]

yeah he wanted to accept second trade window then decline then laugh at u and it backfired

 

[Sillymonkey]

Nothing wrong with it.

He did something stupid and learned from it.

 

[The Five of Jokers]

He had a chance to look at the second window to make sure... his fault

You win

 

[Phanz]

Haha good job. You did the right thing... he was trying to get your hopes up but fail LOL. Congratz. ;D