Which one looks better? Signature 1 or Signature 2?

Hello fellow Sythe members.

I need your opinion on which signature you would prefer to pick, if you were the customer buying it. And whatever signature you choose please tell me what you like about it, what you will edit, change on it etc. Notice on Signature 2 "Vouches" has a text box around it, if you can't spot that out, so if you pick that signature let me know if you think that should stay, or remove the text box.


Signature 1:



Signature 2:



Thanks! ​

 

1 but add some background effects

 

I'd go with number 2 if you make the text less rounded.

 

Thank you both for the advice. <3

 

@Gracious For number 2 that you picked, should the text box be around "vouches" or not?

 

I like the second one because of its lighting.

Sythe users are generally more interested in buying 3D text for signatures, so I'd suggest leaning towards improving that sort of style.

 

Ok thanks mate, do you think the text box around "Vouches" should be there or?

 

Ha Thor sure took his time to advertise himself haha. I like the first one more as the second one has some buggy lightning on the left side of it and the box around Vouches looks too much like a button which doesn't really fit there imo.

 

Haha, alright cheers for your advice!

 

Ill go with 1 bud, nice clean design can easily see the name. Also 2 seems really similar to prettygood's so 1 seems more original. Nice sigs in general.

 

I like #2 alot more but there's this square part on the left side that needs to be fixed, I would personally also like to see the text curve slightly less. Good job by thor though

 

I like the second one better, but I think that you should remove the box around "Vouches" and also make the text slightly less curved so that it's easier to read at a glance.

 

Okay, thank you to all who have given me advice on the signatures I appreciate it tyvm. <3

 

Meteor hit the nail on the head for a critique, but I'll add one additional comment. You might want to add the Skype contact section to the bottom one because it's very useful information.

 

Thanks, for your advice.

 

Post your updated work here please

 

Ok, np will do.

 

I think the first one is so much more professional. Every marketfag and their grandmother has a 3D signature with lighting effects that they paid a 16 year old $15 for. I don't like the second one because of how cliche it is and how everyone's signature looks like that when they first join the site.

 

First one, make sure to get the transparency issues fixed, though.

 

#1 by far