Feedback required - Sythe logo

Nice UI, and eh. Maybe we can get a bunch and Richard opens a poll?

 

Nice work Jiwi, I like it In my opinion, the subtext is better. However, Id like to see urs with a big S and small ythe to compare

 

I still think that the drop-shadow should be toned down just a little, 10-20%.

 

Agree with this! Drop-shadow is definitely a big too much.

 

Subtext looks awkwardly placed ^

 

ignore the subtext it's more of a placeholder

 

Bold version looks really shit

 

How about you provide something mildly constructive?
You seem to have an issue putting criticism in that has any substance. Just try to use words and put together a sentence that explains why. If that's too much for you to handle then no worries.

 

O yeah sorry mb i should be more const
bold version looks shit because youre shit at graphics

 

sorry I couldn't hear you over that ban man

 

I'm sort of having this feeling right now. I think the partial dislike for it pertains to not liking change, especially when they've adapted to something for quite a while.

 

I am like this is as well with the logo... I also like and prefer jiwis with the big S lower ythe

 

Over the past days it has definitely grown on me even more and I am all for it. Especially with Jiwi's edits.

 

I like Kiwi's version.

 

I'm still very much in support of Alteranz's old submission from the old competition:

 

SOMEONE finally has their wits about them c.c

I remember my original appeal to this website with the first skin. It was all simple, there wasn't big gaudy logos or graphics or effects or anything. The design in this thread is nice, way better than kina's ugly ass puke fest of a logo, but I am still in love with alteranz' simplistic design.

 

Yeah if it is going to change I definitely want it to be Alt's. Still not sure how he lost that competition.

 

5char

 

Looks great man, loving it.