Banned users miniranks

Since miniranks are limited. Banned users shouldnt have it, the miniranks should be removed from their accounts and probably auctioned or used in giveaways as there are limited amounts

 

stupid idea because if a user was banned accidentally or without cause this would obviously affect them negativity.

 

This was discussed in the past and was denied.

If the user is banned for reasons other than scamming, they will keep their miniranks.

If the user is banned for scamming, the victim can request the transfer of the scammer's miniranks.

 

The current sythe rules for miniranks is good.
As ghast explained ^^.

 

There was a system in place to where banned users would lose their miniranks, and they'd be placed in a "pool" - The plan was for some sort of minigames or events to be created to give users the opportunity to win said ranks after the pool has grown to an acceptable size.

This came with a flaw, however. Users would lose their ranks for ANY ban. Be it a SRB, an accidental ban, a precautionary ban, or otherwise. It was discussed, and ultimately decided that the idea as a whole be scrapped.

The discussion in question can be found here: http://www.sythe.org/approved-suggestions/1643373-retain-mini-ranks-when-banned-unbanned.html

 

There was talk of them being put in to a game or something; but it was never put in motion AFAIK.
As said above, if someone with miniranks scams, the victim can request the miniranks to make up for some of the loss. Otherwise, the banned member may return and removing the miniranks would kind of contradict the "other stipulations" in pardons - in the way that funranks etc are not removed upon unban (generally).

 

Locked as denied/answered.