I have been wondering for a very long time as to whether selling Runescape items/gold was legal or not, so I did a bunch of research over 3 months and found out the answer.
After 3 months of research on this, the short and long of it is that "illegal" is the improper term for it. It is not in violation of any real world laws, such as intellectual property or copyrights. Because the items never leave RS, and Jagex states in their TOS/EULA/PP that "all items are the property of Jagex," the items are never really transfering in ownership. No matter who is using the item at the time, it still belongs to Jagex. So you cannot be held responsible for selling their property or said to be breaking the law, because you are not selling the item itself, only the license to use it, which you have rightfully acquired by playing their game.
Unfortunately, just because it is not illegal does not mean you can't be prosecuted. Jagex states in their TOS that they have the right to prosecute should they feel that they "suffer any loss or damage from the breach of their contract." Gold farming breaks their TOS (and their EULA and PP I'm sure), so if they could present in court acceptable evidence that could prove they have suffered loss or damage from your business, you could be sued.
*TOS stands for Terms of Service*
*EULA stands for End User License Agreement*
*PP stands for Privacy Policy*
After 3 months of research on this, the short and long of it is that "illegal" is the improper term for it. It is not in violation of any real world laws, such as intellectual property or copyrights. Because the items never leave RS, and Jagex states in their TOS/EULA/PP that "all items are the property of Jagex," the items are never really transfering in ownership. No matter who is using the item at the time, it still belongs to Jagex. So you cannot be held responsible for selling their property or said to be breaking the law, because you are not selling the item itself, only the license to use it, which you have rightfully acquired by playing their game.
Unfortunately, just because it is not illegal does not mean you can't be prosecuted. Jagex states in their TOS that they have the right to prosecute should they feel that they "suffer any loss or damage from the breach of their contract." Gold farming breaks their TOS (and their EULA and PP I'm sure), so if they could present in court acceptable evidence that could prove they have suffered loss or damage from your business, you could be sued.
*TOS stands for Terms of Service*
*EULA stands for End User License Agreement*
*PP stands for Privacy Policy*




